Winnipeg Free Press

Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - September 2, 1920, Winnipeg, Manitoba Manitoba free press Winnipeg thursday. September 2 1920 executive unto of from pase recited that the provinces de ired a Federal Union with the Crown a Constitution similar in Prin Ciple to that of the United re that such a Union would conduct the welfare of the provinces and Romore the interests of the British Constitution unalterable the of the fed a i raiment to alter the cons Titu of Dominion sir James said any Ion on a supreme legis my in a written Constitution creates that body with regard the mod of modifying that con is a Fetter on the Freedom the legislature yet such Irick fro Dom does not prevent state . For instance the United Rit aies can Only Amend its Federal Constitution by consent of three fourths of the states composing it mid yet no one denies that it is a Sovereign nation. So the fact that the Dominion cannot Amend its Constitution i not inconsistent with com plete National and enter National status. A self governing nation Many of the statesmen of King Ianul and of the dominions speak now of Canada As a self governing nation in the same class As the United King Dom and both of course within the Empire and practice and precedent Are beginning to justify it. That is consistent with the recital in the. Act that Canada was intended to have a a Constitution similar in principle to i that of the United kingdom but it j is inconsistent with sections 55, 56 and. 57, had they not fallen into Dos i etude. They provide that the gov prior general May Reserve a Bill for j he approval of the and that the King in Council May disallow an act. The time limit is years under these Only one act was disallowed and that was of a. Domestic character and on the suggestion of the Dominion Trovor Merit i in s7s. Then the sane mid in cilia tory method was introduced of representations and communications about any act of the dominions which might injuriously affect. The Liniev its of tilt or of any important part of it. And satisfactory adjust j merits have usually resulted. H May i be urged that the very existence of such sections win cause a govern ment which passed an offending act i to be More reasonable in repealing Lor modifying it. The big stick May j compel compliance but it Doc not create harmonious feeling without which the Empire will fade away. 1 Keith in his Imperial i nity and the is certain that j actual disallowance of aws when i passed May be regarded As now of i Solete in Case of. Responsible govern if these sections Are now in appropriate and obsolete and the methods of free interchanging of views Nyrl resulting adjustments has become the settled Rule they might be modified accordingly and a Plaus Ible argument would then be taken from the agitator of separa the privy Council judgment as1 proof of Canada s changing status sir James quotes lord Hal Dane in the Russell Case when he said the Empire has developed and More and More the principle 01" self government especially in of criminal jurisdiction is being allow and that Canada has Home Rule and i am not disposed to go Back on Bonar Law als o said ii parliament. Dominion Home. Rule Means the right of decide their Owr. he then showed that the former supremacy of Imperial legislation Over that of the dominions was be coming a discarded principle. In 1911 the Imperial copyright act provided that it was not to apply to a self governing Dominion unless declared by the legislature of such dominions to be in Force there. Sir James adds1 if the Equality of. Status in the British Empire of the self governing nations is a reality the doctrine of supremacy of Imperial legislation must be Laid aside As an outworn garment the Don t be afraid to ask the officials of this Bank Are glad to explain to you anything you do not know about banking. Understand All the details of every Money Tran Section you make. There is no necessity for you to be confused or in doubt. Ask us. If you do not understand at. First ask us again. We Are Here to serve. We Welcome the Small regular depositor Winnipeg for College fall term now open enrol at any time Dat or evening classes Corner Portage and Edmonton opposite Boyd Block Call for an interview. Office open every Day from . To 6.15 ., and on monday wednesday and Friday from 7.30 to 10 Phone a5843-a5844. This Lovely Home Cash balance a rancid n1755-asc03 Portage ave. Store Large store 2-1x120, in builders Exchange Portage and Hargrave to let. Immediately. W. J. Christie co. Cor. Phone a3307. 300 Paris building. Fashion of which has passed in order to remover the territorial limitation Canadian legislation in Dominion parliament at its last session a re slut tin to amond the so that any enactment the parliament of can Ada otherwise within the Legisla Tive authority of the parliament shall operate Rind be deemed to have oper ated according to its intention in manner and to the same exult is if enacted by the parliament of the United King net a subordinate act sir tames said it was a disputed question appeals to the privy Council in purely Canadian matters placed Canada in the Posi Tion of a subordinate nation. He expressed no opinion himself but said that when Canadian lawyers United in asking for the abolition of such appeals in civil cares the prac Tice would end. Dealing with to evolution of treaty making Powers he referred to the establishment of the Canadian department of extern no affairs in. Woo. The reciprocity agreement of 1911 was negotiated by Canadian ministers directly with the u. S. Government. In pursuance of a Reso Lution passed at. The Imperial con Ference in 1911, British treaties now always contain a reservation that they do not apply to the dominions without their consent. Representatives on the league then Canada and the other Dom Inions became members of the league of nations there was some doubt whether they could have representatives on the Council. Sir Robert Borden obtained from presi Dent Wilson Premier Clemenceau and Premier l Loyd George a definite written Assurance that the Domin ions would have this right. Sir James adds it is submitted that As to the president is entrusted the Power of dealing with foreign s tates. When he consented to the admission of the do Mir for. Delegates into the conference 4.l Versailles and when he signed the interpretation mentioned he committed the United states Theof Uia dominions in the league of nations and whatever action the Senate May take it cannot. Withdraw the recognition Given through the president of the autonomous status of the Imperial chamber rejected a Constitution for the Empire was1 discussed at the first Imperial conference when a proposal for an Imperial elective chamber with legislative and executive Powers was rejected. Or. Asquith said it would endanger the authority of the United kingdom in Many grave matters in regard to which could not a the subject was again discussed at the. Imperial conference of 1917, and while action was deferred till after the War the con Ference went on record As favouring recognition of the right of the Dom Inions and India to an adequate i voice in foreign policy and in foreign relations and should provide effective arrangements for continuous consultation in All important matters j common. Imperial concern and for such necessary concerted action founded on consultation As the several governments May deter Asquith View contradicted sir James proceeded of this1 and the necessities of the War there evolved an Imperial Cabinet which is to meet annually to Confer about foreign policy and matters connected therewith and come to decisions in regard to them which subject to the econ Rol of their own parliaments they . The responsible Heads of the governments of. The Empire will then severely execute. Thus in j a few years Converse of or. I Asquith s View is being transmitted into a political fact. It must be noticed however that the Imperial Cabinet has no Power to carry its decisions into effect. Participating governments Are expected to do that fold no ordinarily will. Will this policy of an Imperial conference and an Imperial cab inet develop into an organic Union of the self governing nations and India with a common representative body empowered to legislate and an executive Council responsible to that body of elected representatives or into a league of British executive authority vanishing to the signing of the peace treaty he said that in International Law the Empire has a unitary existence consequently though the dominions became orig Inal members of the league of nations they Werp not parties to the treaty of Versailles because they had not been in inter National Law As Sovereign states. He added As a. Political fact the legislative supremacy of the British parliament Over the dominions has disappeared iatid1 the theory of executive Unity of the Empire is also commencing vanish. While the peace conference adhered to the principle of the Unity of the Empire Cor the purpose of War and , they acceded to the demands of the dominions for separate representation in the league to guard the interests of those lawyers urged to Public service sir Janice in dealing with the affairs of the Canadian bar association suggested that incorporation of the association would bring Many advantages. He also urged the Law yers to undertake their share of nubile service. He said through a eneral neglect of that service in our country of popular suffrage our people Are in danger of the despotism not so much of individuals As of classes organized on the principle of every one for himself and the Devil take the hinder most which results As the de in would have it in his league of British nations a league in being Cave Imperial relationships and can Ada s part therein were discussed at tonight s gathering of the Canadian bar association. The sneakers were Ari count Cave a lord Justice of the court of appeals of great Britain and Hon. W. E. Raney attorney general for Ontario. Lord Cave s re Ference to Imperial relations came at the end of an address As a former Home Secretary and so had been Able to present an intimate View of British War legislation. The league of nations lord Cave was a grand Conception but much time and Effort must be expended before it came to full fruition. Meantime there was in exist ence the league of British nations. And the Bond which United its great component units was no Chain of possessions but the hand clasp of men. It was founded on two principles the autonomy of each and the voluntary co operation of All. And while we Are True to these Princi Ples to each other and to our King can prevail against or. Raney spoke of Canada s growth to nationhood suggesting a reconstitution of the judicial committee of the e privy Council with jurisdiction to consider questions arising Between the different nations represented. The minister of Justice presided. Canada s part in War lord Cave opened with feeling Tri Bute to the part which Canada had played in the War. Making the sense of brotherhood deeper and More vibrant. He gave a. Review of the War i Nim Trency legislation in Aiu and of the part which members of the and bar. Had. Played. Lord Cave remarked in pass British peer turns ranch Man in Canada Viscount Arbuthnott Viscount Arbuthnott new head of the ancient scotch House is now a ranch j owner in Canada. Tho 7iew Viscount and his wife own the spotted Luke in Alberta and Are How residing there. He. Recently succeeded to the title. Ing Resolute in adopting of Mili tary service which we ad6pied just in time and without which the War would have been principles eclipsed lord Cave was of the. Opinion that the British government made an error at the commencement of the War in. the declaration of London is guide for contraband. Iowa Cunys when not Only armies but whole made War. And when Success or failure depended As much upon spirit As upon prowess in arms meticulous rules As to what was absolute and what was conditional contraband or As to was and what was not a continuous voyage destined for the enemy Sim ply would not work. In saying lord Cave added. I do not intend for a moment depreciate the value of the established rules of International Law or of Weil considered agreements operating in War time. England kept her agreements and observed Ali the rules by which she was bound. T3ven Germany kept some of them and there was no ble Liger Etc. Nation which did not pay at least a verbal homage to theurin. Caples of International . It can not e denied that those principles suffered in this War a partial eclipse but i still think they were of service. I Hope and believe that with the and vent of a. More reasonable spirit and tinder the fostering influence of th-3 league of nations they will speedily renew their strength and i can conceive of no better augury than the agreement recently framed at the Hague for the establishment of a permanent court of International relations with dominions lord Cave referred to the effect of upon the constitutional re lations Between the old country and the dominions. For a lie said some of the Ablest states men of the Cham and others whose names will occur considering How Best a. Further link could be forged Between the Central and do minion governments which should be neither so stiff Gall nor so weak As to Oren under a Strain. It May be that the problem has been solved quietly and almost unconsciously fas our habit is by the establishment of the Imperial War Cabinet As an effective Council of the Empire. That As Sembly of the leading statesmen of the self governing parts of the Empire first called together in lot for the purpose of discussing the conduct of the War and some of the higher issues of Imperial policy proved to be of so much service both to its members and to the countries concerned that it determined at the instance of the Brit ish prime minister to keep it in being. And so other meetings took place at a later crisis of the War and again when the terms of peace were under consideration. The Ai first it Xmas nothing an Una qualified Success and to Many of us it seems possible that the Imperial War Cabinet May if the Imperial conference should so deter Imine drop its Middle name and. While retaining wholly voluntary and consultative May become in world affairs the Centre of the autonomous nations of an Imperial common wealth. League of British nations the league of lord Cave concluded is a great Concep Tion but much time Effort must be expended before it comes to full fruition. In the meantime there is a league in being. A league Strong effective and peace Loving nurtured in Independence skied in self government ambitious for no world Empire but Only for a world the of the British nations. The Bond which unites its great component Britain. Canada Newfoundland Australia new Zea land and South no Chain of Possession but the hand clasp of free men. It is founded on two principles the autonomy of each and the voluntary co operation of and while we True to those principles to each other and to our King no enemy can prevail against . Election will not Settle league Issue says Taft speaking before the Canadian bar association at luncheon today Wil Liam Howard Taft former president of the u. S. And official representative of the american bar association dealt with the constitutional aspects of the league of nations. I Don t he declared that those people who contend against the Power of the u. S. To make contracts and enter into obligations with other nations fully realize How completely such a construction of the cons Titu Simon would relegate our great nation and government to the limbo of infants and irresponsible great authority on jurisprudence. The luncheon of the Canadian bar association at which or. Taft. Spoke was attended by his excellency the governor general members o f the Dominion and provincial govern ments leading fixtures of the Cun Arjian Bench Ami Neil n Pien t a the Reg i life far entity. Premier William of Saskatchewan was in the Shnir and welcoming or. Taft referred As one of the greatest authorities on jurisprudence and Iii i unit tonal Law on this tie remarked humorously that or. Taft Hud now been appointed to sit on a canadian1 and. That it be a Kod thing for Canada to do away with certain features of our naturalization Laws As to make the a citizen of the Dominion following or. Tatt s. Speech. Sir Douglas Hazen Rose to move that the representative of the. American bar association be made a honorary member of Ilie Canadian bar association a. Motion which was carried with enthusiasm by the meeting. Definition of league. In opening or. Taft expressed the. and fraternal feeling of the american bar association the president of which or. Hampton Carson Haa requested him to attend the meeting in Ottawa. What was the covenant of the league of nations asked or. Taft. It was a partnership agreement made up of kinds of stipulations the first of which were self restraining. They bound the nations to certain restraints calculated to prevent or reduce the chances of War. Then there were agreements directed to wards penalize in nations which failed to restraining covenants. These penalties must be imposed by the United action of the members As there was no executive court with the Power to enforce them. There was nothing but con science and Good Faith t o see that they were carried out. The strength Portne league of nations said or. Taft must depend on the spirit of Coop ration and Good Faith. If that was lacking it did not matter How Strong the convention were made the league must fail. Election will not decide Issue. Or. Taft said that the result of the e presidential election in the u. S. Would not necessarily mean the decision of the people of the u. S re Garding the league of nations. There were other issues involved in the election. It that to enter the league the . Would have to part with some of her Sovereign pow ers. This Contention to disputed the fact at the matter was that a sovereignty which could not enter in to agreement with other nations was a minor and ought to have a guar Dian. Any nation living with other nations must have the Power to enter into agreements with them. A Sov Ereign had the right to enter into agreements and he had also the right to if his conscience would permit it. It would be a great interference with the usefulness of the . And also the usefulness other neighbors if the . Might not enter into agreements with other nations to perform Cert non acts in consideration of their performing the same or other a Sovereign state _ Hon. A. E. Raney attorney general of Ontario spoke strongly in favor of Canada undertaking the Fuh. Responsibility of. A Sovereign state within the Empire. He said under the new order which is now will in the future Amend her own Constitution and make her own treaties. The issues of peace and War will be determined both actually and technically at Ottawa and the governor general of Canada will be appointed by the Kin gon the nomination of his majesty Council for Canada. Moreover a nation cannot be a nation and have its ultimate court of judicial Appeal located outside its own boundaries and Independent of its o in harvesters Drifting Back though the Harvest Days Are not yet Over there is a noticeable Drift ing Back eastward of men who came out to help the Farmers of the Prairies Garnet their crops. Among them yesterday was a Young student i whose bashfulness will have to be i dotted if he achieves Ami i the ministry. He has made i his second harvesting trip and with the proceeds ii putting himself i rough Colleen in Ottawa. He left i the rain Fields Early he wished to enter school without los ing any of the Lerm. By we. Mcpherson by h. Gray son m is. We. P. Smith of los Antolos cslif., who says Tarlac completely restored her health when no one believed she would Ever be Wall again hns gained thirteen pounds. I will never Stop praising Tarlac for it has restored my health when everyone who knew of my dreadful condition had no idea i would Ever get Well. Two years ago following an Acci Dent 1 began suffering from indigestion and severe stomach trouble. I grew worse rapidly that my health soon became perfectly wretched. My stomach became so weak 1 could t eat the simplest food or even drink a Glass of milk without suffering for hours afterwards. I was extremely nervous and palpitation of the heart so badly at times i would almost faint. My circulation was very poor. I had no color and weighed Only eighty one pounds. It seemed i just gradually starving by degrees and i had almost Given up Hope. I after the Best medical treatment failed to help me travel and a change of surroundings was advised so 1 i plied nearly All Over the United states and had treatment every Placa i went but always with the same Dis j appointing results. How i stood my suffering is More than i can Tell and ii became so despondent that life j seemed hardly Worth jiving. I that is just the condition i was in when i began taking Tarlac. When my husband first suggested Tarmac i told him i had in it but the next Day he bought me a bottle and to my great Surprise it seemed to agree with me so i kept on taking it. The results speak for themselves. I have gained thirteen pounds in weight. And i feel perfectly Well in every Way. My appetite is splendid and i eat just anything i want and never have the slightest symptom of indigestion. I. Am of Happy Over the recovery of my health that i feel just like telling everybody about this wonderful the above remarkable statement was-., by mrs. William p. Smith a Well known and highly respected resident of los Angeles calif., residing at 133 East Avenue 36. Tarlac is sold in Winnipeg by Lig Gett s drug stores Elliott argue and co., Mather and by the leading drug gist0 in every Kennedy Larmour real estate Loans and invest ments. Removed from 801 Union Bank to 713 Mclntyre Block Canoe wanted if you have one for phone a8315, or. Write Princess Street. Wanted Central location Square Box 1615 free press auction Sale of surgical instruments appliances and office furnishings at the Saleroom 264 Smith Street Friday sept. 3 at 2 Including High tension Victor x j Ray frequency Cabinet apparatus. Fischer High frequency apparatus. Wicker Couch and electric Beds Quan Tity of surgical instruments White enamel surgical bowls Black upholstered operating chair red Plush operating Cli Aik 2 Oak settees with Loose leather cushions Oak Library table Roll top desk office chair desk typewriter chair Oak wardrobe 4 chairs apothecary and. Physician Scales Whito enamel washstand. 3 carpets Moose head 1 Large Golden Oak Cabinet mahogany Bookcase typewriter desk. 1 new Sheldon Vibrator Quantity of vacuum electrodes electric . Surgical instrument Cabinet White Ena Mel stand and irrigator with wheels. Acting under instructions we will sell by auction the above mentioned goods. Now on View. W. H. Auctioneer. Phone a5333. 264 Smith St. Auction Sale of a i 1 Ford ton truck 1 Ford Sedan at 346 Ellice ave. In sept 2nd at 2 o clock. Instructed by the . Or Etc. As follows on of " chairs steel folding Oak linoleum. 2 China dressers Iron Beds sprint and tresses also 2 new a and Larce Chen tables chairs. To. Terms Cash. H. Gray son auctioneers phone a1071. 345 Ellice a by Frank Pearson Mclean s Sale stables auction Sale of 50 head of horses thursday sept. 2 at 2 Including team of hares eix and seven years old weighing about 1.450 in Good shape and extra Good set of harness. A team. Brown and Black about and harness. Two year old Bay gelding that shows Promise of a Good track horse also a. Dark Grey yearling gelding and a team of extra Good general purpose geldings in first class shape and ready to go to work and about ten other useful horses. The above will be sold without re serve. We also offer a 2% in. Bain Wagon with grave Box. Don t miss this Sale. Private sales at All times. Mclean s Sale stables. Cor. Arlington and Alexander. Phone n6077. Superb auction Sale. Heintzman co. Player piano like Aton mahogany bedroom suite comprising Dresser Chiff Onier bed som no and 2 chairs. A set of this Quality has Seldom Baba sold at genuine ish Bug 9x12. Genuine turd ii Tan Hail Kunner. tha practically unobtainable Bow. Three Wilton and a sinister squares pre War Quality. Mas Sive Cathedral Oak dining room suite. At the residence 833 Dorchester ave. Fri sept 3 at 2 o clock. Instructed by or. Bal Linston who ii leaving the City i will sell his costly and almost new House furnishings. In eluding elegant tapestry upholstered Chesterfield and 2 chairs to match. Sheraton Secretary electric fan. Valu. Able pictures drop head sewing machine Wilton Stair naj pct sectional Bookcase Rattan chair dinner and Tea set curtains enamelled Bea. Enamelled Dresser mahogany parlor Tabie. Toronto Couch laundry and Garden requisites terms Cash. The above Are Quality and should interest those same i conduct All sales persons ii your furnishings Are Pood it to let Nie handle your Sale. Frank Pearson auctioneer phone a6569. By Frank Pearson stupendous auction Sale Complete furnishings 14-room residence at my Sale rooms 306 Edmonton St., Street thursday sept. 2 at 2 o clock. This is a Large and Good collection of Nedium class including 3 brass bylds. C High Trade enamel a Beds i solid Oak dressers glands mahogany 5-piece parlor suite valuable leather Younse. Toronto court ref air a practical prescription for sour acid stomach nine tenths of ii cases of stomach trouble nowadays Are caused by too j much acid. In the beginning the Stom Ach i self is not diseased but it this acid condition is allowed to continue the acid is Verv Likely to eat into the Stem i Ach Walls and produce gastritis with stomach ulcers. This rentier n Radi Cal surgical operation necessary even to prolong life. Therefore an am stomach is really a dangerous Condi Tion and shout ii he treated seriously. The excess acid or stomach hype acidity ran easily be neutralized by Bis rated magnesia taken teaspoonful posts in a Glass of water after each . Lor Goi quantities May. If Neces As it is absolutely harmless. To sure to ask your druggist for Hie pure Bis rated especially prepared for this on Arlington Street South Portage Avenue starting in. Basement is Stone Well finished and Well furnished. Gas stove for laundry. Closed in Xoai bins to prevent dust. and a hot water ground doors to Hall Side Entrance to kit Chen separate doors connect pantry to Kitchen and to Din ing room drawing room and Danng room connected by sliding doors making one Long room for dancing if desired. Den with fireplace. Bedrooms and sleeping Balcony Iava Torie sep Arate from Bath. Hot water has Ting in every room electric fixtures cupboards in every room. This House could not be built for. . You can buy it for for permission to View s an ply . Andrews company 431 main Street. . A1175. Fire up with Empire Furnace Lump and stove Drumheller Empire Coal go. Ltd. 603 electric railway Chambers. Phone n6357-8. Orator. Happy thou lit Range solid Cak dining room suite. 4 a e. Library chairs. 10 Fine carpels still carpets. 15 Emali Wilton and Minster rugs. Rattan living room set. Mac Frany fit tapestry fled. 2 tapestry arms chairs s in velour Portieles child s or rot Menn Case Library table parlor tort Ware Oak sideboard. Oak Hall stand pictures brass Jardiniere Silver Tea Sel. Kitch i Cabinet Etc. Terms Cash. My sales Are attending Frank Pearson. Auctioneer. Phone a6563. By Frank Pearson for Sale privately magnificent antique Grandfather s clock by John Knox of tame for is easily Worth . Satisfactory j evidence As to Antiquity can be Siven. I can personally recommend this As a Fleat bargain. Also for Sale Holtzman co. Prancl piano As Good As new. Owner is or. Costa Sia i and has cabled me instructions to Posi Lively Price Only . If Soli at once. I apply for above to i Frank Pearson auctioneer. I specialist in High class furnishings. 306 Edmonton is. Phone a6569. By j. F. Haynen Bailiff Sale Dodge for Quick Sale Cash engine in a1 order. New top just put on. Estate late or. Modt rold 786 Dorchester Avenue restaurant i i equipment household furniture Tea sugar and canned goods. Glassware u Fine ranges. 5 pictures Etc., on thurs., sept. 2nd at 2 o clock butter boxes butter boxes for immediate ship ment in Carload or any Quantity desired. Other boxes made to order and delivered promptly capital City Box co. Ltd. Edmonton Alberta. Harrison at my auction rooms. 338 notre Avenue. Instructed by bailiffs. Hopps co. Other clients. I sell by suction Tea. Sugar canned goods. Dishes glassware table. 1 Ather armchair. Toronto Couch Fine Springs and mattresses. Cookie. Utensils curtains Dresser. J table child s cot. And contents 2 trunks and c i bundles clothing and 3 j ing cases and contents. 2 party Kitchen chairs. C 2 june ranges. Couches. Con Mats 5 rugs Quantity pictures c cutlery _-tc., Etc. Terms Cash at. Sale. J. F. Haynen auctioneer phone a6405. Patterns As you wan them when you them. Empire lightning Rod co., us 1w St. . A70ffl. - ;