Winnipeg Free Press

Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - December 8, 1920, Winnipeg, Manitoba Of trial Section pages is to 28 of Liberty of of civil 1920 printed mid Send Najy the Stan Toba frees a compar Faur Apted under the of it Ita us place of 304 Orlton in the general beat stored the general for through malls in the British literal Inland Revenue no superstate control w Al Resolution brought Upin the of the league of 1 place the worlds supplies of jaw pre Jar the Council of the had Little in it which like Canada could the Resolution was pre Gustav of and was supported by natives of Italy and while the most i criticism made against it came from the representatives of ported by the representatives of Australia and new the fact that it should have been proposed to throw resources of raw material into a common Pool with the Dis of the Pool in the control of the league indicates on the part a remarkable Lack of knowledge about the National which Are developing in some of the newer i of Canada to have agreed to any such proposal have destroyed the value of the league in this country and appeals it the privy Council x Appeal an infringement of the legislative of the Dominion by Herbert Profe Oboroff jurisprudence and common Mcgill Montreal the question disputes arising in Canada receive their Feria settlement in Ottawa or in Lon Don is really a very simple one if Only it is examine Din the of Well established Issue is so frequently obscured either by the introduction of irrelevant and considerations or by As soda Tori with part politics that it is Worth while making fresh Effort to Clear the ground in order that we May see exactly what the question for from the Golden to the guide me with song kind Muse deaths dark Shade keep Ine 4n Accord wit boy still in of Art and truth Bear with old memory child of loves the Good and youth and thou Are nigh to Sophocles and playmate of Queen of night draw earthy voice grows faint decision really let us examine some of Theofi in we the Are retention for of of the have been the people who would have resisted such an overseas Appeal is an essential part lot the Canada and the ii uie Vonu Between uan Aua aim me j no Canadian a government would Ever commit Ganada Ioia what does this argue a this was behind Rowels and sir teter8 repudiation of the pooling they were Canadian Public sentiment to their colleagues in the my spirit fails still with whether death sleep or mens Back pay to the editor of thanks f pub Lishing letter in your 1s apparently the publicity i your valuable paper had desired because cheques from1 May 1 As per Chicago the time Jay it is still far offt when nations and govern face sufficiently disinterested and idealistic to put their a common store to be administered for the common Good by Jome super National that such a Pool would Beso administered la foe present stage of evolution is not the Resolution in the of european diplomacy the in so in Cutie has those functions controlled by the great and pooling the worlds ites urses Lindertt league would wish to the retention was right theae1 minor inconveniences would nol justify us in making the but Therea reason Why the anomaly is preserved lies in the failure of its supporters to realize that it is essentially an infringement of the Legisla Tive rights of the if can f Ada is state she must have All it Means if th0se functions of jurisdiction which a b Nave a in Vancouver 4he necessary attributes of state of Empire will be weaken Hood Ai implies and led if the dispute Between them is not of legislative executive and brought for final settlement before a j judicial these three fun Board of lawyers sitting in sons Are so closely interwoven that to state such argument in they cannot really be and control to the great Man True form is to show its Absurdity strength of the which hold the Empire together May be measured by the contribution which Canada made to the Allied cause in the late if a statute had been passed in 1914 forbidding and b to carry their litigation further than the preme court at can anyone seriously suggest that the of the Canadian forces in France would diminished by a single sir Deforg Fosters stand against Resolution should have Dirl fied to borne extent the minds of members of the league Oslo the attitude of no european it outside of Europe that flu great stores of raw material and on of the Ocean the Jwj Jesuron that they should ostensibly by the league of Butin by european governments operating on imperialistic principles is too that would be push thing the of the league considerably beyond the realities of the existing1 any in its present stages to convert the league into a super elate or a super National governing body trill wreck there Are few motions Trio would take orders or permit their Domestic policy to be inter Jeri with by any extra Atlonia even though Toi representation on the theory of centralization has few supporters and reason is the knowledge that wherever the centralized the foot of the throne another instance of the Appeal to irrelevant sentiment is be found in the argument that it is the highest British a right in interference with one is really a right of interference with the the doubts of Quebec there remains one objection to any this objection is one which deserves the and sympathetic it is Felt by a considerable Section of opinion in Quebec that the Protection of French rights under the terms of confederation is More Likely to be safeguarded by the privy Council than by the supreme court of let us see whether this is really to my mind the strict Observance in letter and in spirit of the terms Quebec entered the do a readers note3 my world within the writer in the contemporary he View has resurrected a Book that might Well go in the catalogue with lord Chester Fields lettered to his All freight hand and the lesser letters to Here received their Back pay by bluestocking both Chesterfield and Chapone wrote in the eighteenth but they wrote from differ ent moral the lady greater in they had this in Rote without any thought of the Book under review in con to a Daught being letters for a new years gift an divided As follows family and Chil and the daughters name was Elizabeth she was scarcely in her after All he her father married her at Nineteen to the third Earl of Ches Aman of morose disposition ind violent according to his and Elizabeth became he Mother of the famous Earl who wrote the letters to she died when he Wafe a child and left free other sons and two in lord Halifax coun Sel to his beloved Young daughter do not imagine vainly that things will be altered for your the position of n this world was when he thinks of what May be before h he shrinks As if he was and he shows her by cunning diplomacy and by affected she May make the Best of a selfish or faithless or miserly or Drunken Hus All that for but system has its Centre there also is the controlling and it would Idle to ask overseas nations to sink their National identity and become Meready mrcos in a Large scheme of ostensibly representative but in reality dominated from european the surest Way to kill the As Rowell pointed is to try j and use it for such a in the Pool the natural re sources of the league this Issue actually cropped and the league As a superstate was frankly condemned by the Canadian the league is Only in its infant stages the Best it can Hope to do for some time to come is to serve As a forum in which difficult or dangerous International problems can be ventilated and discussed the league will be what its members make and it will extend its executive Powers Only in accordance with the Sanction of All its but before its Power is such that it can act Over the head of National governments very Satis factory guarantees must exist that the spirit of imperialism has passed four privilege 01 every is Iusa Suu Cui i h be a Leto carry his grievance for Rei minion is an obligation of Goi utely binding upon the whole peo ple of the terms of the a treaty it really Only be altered by the free consent of both and if Observance could be secured by the the privy Council i should vote for the retention of the Appeal even at the expense of logical but i believe the danger to be More imaginary in the first place it May be pointed out that has always an effective representation of French judges on the supreme but is j to 1 dress to the foot of the if the King personally was in any Way concerned with the decision of cases in the privy Council there might be some Force in this kind of for the strength of sentiment is by no Means to be disregarded but everyone knows perfectly Well that the Kin has no More influence Over the decisions of the privy Council than he has Over those of the supreme court of the Cana Dian judges hold the Kings commis Sion in exactly the same Way and represent the King to exactly the Hie Viii it we e same extent As do their Brethren of j not in the the privy the there is usually a lawyer in interest on this Page will he found two contributions about a question which has at last become a matter of general Public the suitability of continuing to accept the judicial committee of the privy Council As the final court in Cana Australia All of these will be determined finally by the supreme courts of but questions Between nations represent ii in the International great Britain for or be tween Canada or Newfoundland or Between South Africa and aus the substantial difference Between them not in train Edih present their relation but in j a Quebec Appeal the fact that one Bench is appointed i but he is to be a on the advice the Canadian and he other on the advice of the British Man government the litigant is brought the french7canadian Point no to the toot of the throne in London than he would be in Otta Bee to remember that history the acutes though the counsel who have us How it Foron Sec gone to Europe at his expense May Tion of a cation to rely some possibly have the Opportunity of be outside of ing presented to their tits special rights one of the protestant part of Ulster Ped of sentimental verbiage the has in the Long run Tseu argument about the foot of the ing but Fps ass realty comes to this that it the to uphold it throne really comes 10 me t Trish is better to bring Canadia cases body of the Irish there is ample advice of another kind on other religion is exalted that in which she has teen brought up is she is not to expect too much gratitude from her Chil children when Neces Isitt deny them he admonishes love against Pear As the Root of their of ser she is told that nature makes no distinction of inequality that is undoubtedly Between them by rank and Breeding that in kindness usage is the right of she must not give just cause to the least servant to complain of the want of what is the Art of spending Wise y involves much she indecent Thrift nor Purchase clothes too much try everything first n your before you alow t a place in and is it not sound Domestic Economy n All matters within her Good Breeding should never be wanting by which he Means Ordinary kindly carried to extremes it is Good for nothing he ascribes a he an airy thing who sails up and Down the and looks As if she to pay a a futile Hay her wrapped flattery and Fine to again a guard Well her actions Evet to eyes towards men is a Nice Yective enemy is always abroad he advises a to make seven an towards the Graver an not to be like the girls ways revisit t for Benefit of your who comprise a very big percentage of u perhaps you might like to know the sequel my audacity in writing to the press concerning a matter the their for having spoken and stated the two facts and the i am this Day dismissed from the by order of superintendent who stated the charge wag writing to the presic and falling in loyalty my comes ten years faithful Loyal and True including four and also the Confidence of the com Pany when in to the extent that i was placed in charge of last years Victory loan and in 1919 handled the red collections for employees at the in might i Appeal to you this letter the same prominence you gave previous in the Hope it May have the effect of checking other employees taking any such an indiscreet action As the writer As the freight agent Here said when notifying dismissal it is not always policy to state the truth in Harey fort 30i invitation to Carvell to editor of the free press your Issue of saturday carvery chairman of the railway is reported e that the Public not think ing the increase in rail Way rates that was impose Don the Public by does car vell expect the people to meet him at Al the railway stations and pro test i would to some of our meetings he there would find a Strong sentiment not Only against the increase rates but also against the present Man of that Board and the Way he is treating the West and those who Are protesting against those in creases which Are an added Burden on the Public and especially on the Farmer with i take this Opportunity of inviting or Carvell to attend the Brandon Convent olt on january he there will find the True senti ment of the Farmers of the West John Tom forty years ago and Jerry of were visiting friends in the opened new office on James annual of the a record4pf unexampled develop prom the Tinong the Many memorable feat ures of the commemoration of the fiftieth anniversary establishment which was celebrated in Winnipeg May be mentioned the special num Ber of the Manitoba free in a special supplement of Twenty two containing Twenty one signed it tells the Story of the be ginning of Western Canada and the founding and development of Man the record is one of almost unexampled material development and in the Broad lines traced great Western newspaper comprehensive record of an eventful half Century has been the Manitoba free which so Miraboy represents the Pfeiler Prairie has in this Issue notably contributed to a notable and dressing gowns can it command the support of any if Oviet gov i Canadian who has a real sense of article Herbert of the Law faculty of my sell puts the Case for the termination of the Appeal with any conviction to every mind which approaches consideration of the question without violent prepouses Sions in favor of things As they it Coni mend the article to our for careful tie letter on the same but defending the follows the with which we Are becom ing too of attempting to demonstrate that the judicial com Nettee supplies a service which we cannot provide for often Jakes the form of a Bald As that Canada cannot provide a Tragiai these speculations what is due to the National dignity of is country the real question let us then Brush these irrelevancies aside try to ascertain the True principle which should govern our attitude towards the privy count Oil to my mind the Issue is Between those who regard Canada As a True state and those who regard her As Only partially relying upon great Britain to Supply what Ever is deficient in her own Winnipeg Curling club was when Jim Ruttan and Mcmillan elected the presbytery of Manitoba appointed Scott to organize a con at West and sustained the Cali from Emerson to r years ago the new eur tag rink at Portage was the first Galihe Beins played Iby rinks skipped respectively by and the former and was by Ai social gathering arranged by the s Bell and j Jackson were elected of Prince Ruperts Royal the Adibe May Macy other such might be the Best safeguard for the rights of i Esin her sympathetic cd operation larger part of the people of the treaty of confederation it is remind the eng Lis speaking population that the same Rule applies to thins Arr sometimes said about Quebec and its people which ought not to be things which serve no purpose but i a promote Dan on this philosopher Foite he of sixty along heel6and narrow pupils cite in enrollnient1 twelve schools so ciety1 Library be established m connection the new quarters society i thirty selected Art officer of Andrews agricultural h Fry and r Jones were elected officers of Epe she Tiona apart from the question under consider that question is the Desira of Cana Dian established courts giving the final and authoritative interpretation to Canadia made to the reasonableness propriety of this claim there been no adequate by those who uphold the View that the ultimate judicial authority should be so far a More important matters Are la legislative and administrative and Sugges this Issue has been Long action has sometimes been taken m Flance of the True principle Ortlon Dunal capable of acting As a court last resort but this its obvious reflection upon ton Aston capacity and is to rapidly losing any effective it Ever our Corr Espin other illustrations of our need for an external court w we do not Fink Hie ago it been conceded Low for Many years that in All mat ers of legislation and of executive Overn Merit the last word upon All surely Canadian questions rests with Canada no one in Canada would now tolerate and no one in sri land would propose the enact ment by the British of let us say a bankruptcy act for the would any one venture to suggest that the act should be administered by officials sent Over from a England and responsible to an English then should it be after we have passed our and appointed Canadian officials to administer for us to go to London in order that English chosen by the English us what our own act Means this is the real question which the up holders of the privy Council jurisdiction have to interpretation a Power of legislation for it must always be borne in mind that the of interpretation is essentially a Power of Legisla Wake up Ontario minister of agriculture predicts an influx of ten thousand practical English Tario next Doherty has been himself on the Jobin England and this is to be the we could place ten thousand practical Manmay read but in the words English Farmers in Hosy and our great but we will not said Tion Taat must be obeyed he get them if we do not go after that a territorial dispute Between and Newfoundland could be tried As a lawsuit before the supreme court of Canada is Obi of this sort Call and in this matter of Labrador Boundary the two governments concerned agreed to sub la to the judicial a there is no use in anyone waning in the wore competent court of arbitration hath an absolute authority to written o spoken it is he who is truly Thi lawgiver to All intents and purposes not the person who first wrote o when they were first Uritis Canada has the right of finally in her own Laws it canno truly be said that she has the Olgh defeat is due to a Lack of making few laymen fully understand Tjho not be but from this argument can be deduced in of the judicial committee con Alvs to exercise a right to pass Alpon Canadian is interesting to note that or Meyi the attorney general of in the address before the bar association in which used the abolition of these a suggested that the judicial reconstituted on a might have a of in deciding issues that develop Between the different on belonging to the Britannic to it he said there might deferred not As questions itto Een citizens of or be tween citizens of or Between different provinces Canada or different states of of candidates and policies that would number of youths arrested in new York in the act of robbing a Safe they wanted to get Money with which to hire a lawyer to defend them in another of burglary charge on which they to be in this introduced will be no end to the the Island of on the West coast of Scotland and from which that unit of Canada not Pon an external Pon a Unity in upon the be contribution of different rifts to he common welfare of the do not wish to arouse controversy y dwelling in detail Juifen the unwise hinge that have been said and it us Hope that they belong to the ast i am Only concerned to Point that if we wish to obtain Triol hearted support of or Effort secure the autonomy of we must make t absolutely Clear that the full Observance of the treaty of Ion regarded As a or the sacred obligation by the e of Canadian opinion from Hali a to the will see that upholds the Appeal to the Edi of the free seek your indulgence mine the first i would suggest to whole common Tew Canada and and ionic and to curl info opened at the Thistle rink Bette shrinks selected by the those representing these cold vice pres ident a feature of the com petition being the game skips Mckechinie and which was a an extra end played that resulted in favor of the i Twentyfive the construction work on a line Between Rossland trait a meeting was held to discuss the recommend a tons of the civic Reform with j Ashdown inthe no motion prevailed to express a con Crete opinion on the Binns was elected president of the Northwest Conj Ercyal with b Stephens and a Cox members the sex Twenty years ago the Winnipeg operatic society de l wonder Fol protector to the there is in the Toothill oils and dts infect properties of lifebuoy i Ninfo Tki tit hit it it dont pay to wait until the last you know the finest perhaps jus the size you will be we Are show Hing a splendid rally of the Russell langs Wetton conmda8 and but Somerset Winnipeg a Ordett completed in our Flat Dos eau of pro str 7031 own from adult Loimil Kwh Merom a caches your House on Chr vat Mas mar Nln with a be sheaf Krneti ours from far and near Joa if you haunt in torn remembered them ton can Heinlo the whole matter in Iem than fire minutes by ahop7dont Forcet suitable memorial to the late Sajor to be Hung m the City by Lajoi com Canada for the Lemon from Globe Oshawa reputation for Enterprise will be enhanced by the successor l citizen in the Ruit has Oceen 1 the of and Inte take their precedents from and the administration of the in the old to the Excel a gusts any whole world pays on a life sized a the Hall and Victor to Pingle Long was com the or tags r authorities and asked that the prof Rem about Worth Are in year free of Send to other countries for Lemons when Lemons grown at Home Means of a Tariff the Price might be so raised it engage Lemon then Sider it derogatory Tri Tran Fineva Depute m the last to the Home and in Taino All the Laws which in your saturday morning consumer it but he would be shown Orch o re i wit important this Power of interpretation really when a court Hafi t interpret a statute the difficulty Doe not generally consist in finding of what the legislature meant where the drafts Enof an act hav any Clear idea of what they want t do they generally contrive to make that meaning the problem be fore the judges is commonly that of applying the statute to some state of facts the legislature has failed to Case the court has simply to make it legislates for those cases which parliament might have provided for if Only it had thought Stout no statute and no code can be so perfect As to obviate the necessity for this judicial what in would contend is that this Stork of compleat our statute Law should be done in Canada and not in decision Plain when question is understood Ards of fruits Section and told that it would be unfair and unpatriotic to strike a blow at honest Industry by Kaboush ing or reducing not clap a duty on Lemons and help to make this coun try thoroughgoing Protection its should no shrink from this application of therr fiscal Why not buy the Oshawa organize a Canadian Iemon growers Issue share capital and to Ottawa for Tariff Canada Asfa jink of understanding lord in a of congratulation to new the parts men play the1 Bonds of Empire lmttel9 f patriotism is a of the love of coun that caused thousands of Cana is to Lay Down their is a matter of Are Ertain matters of sentiment that Urell the most sentimental iconoclast would not seek to Many of the Brawny highlanders has voted perhaps it was getting too dear Constantine is reported to have obtained 98 per of the votes of the greek people Thia leaves the other Side with nothing but two per and two per cent int very exam so Long As the question Isi ined in the Clear Light of Prindle the decisi6n is not As upon As it is generally realized that he re Tention privy Council appeals v wac Volt says a Canadian in of House Between Britain and the Tiu to i under stands oa4da by right of birth he can sympathize with the american 5lnt through closest knowl Edge Borni contiguity his histor makes Hal understand by the British he there a National interpreter Between the portions of the kind t Many of the Money to help fight the typhus plague and the near but Only two come across with the Canada for slam great Britain to legislate irrespective of Canadian opinion i Lieve that tie opposition to which relies chiefly vaguest kind of will gradually there Aje of course or from Plain dealer you Castr the government for its Mexico How Isreb Asbie to recognize tha nicely As Mejico a plentiful producer y e lives 1910 1920 external Trade m greater production from the same Plant your present buildings be arranged to take care of growing production needs until construe Tion costs come consult specialists in i expansion without it will study print Tom wish Arles salaries 1910 us suppose that Canadian people do sever the tones connecting them with the privy what court is to fulfil cer Ain of its functions pres ent moment a care is before the the contestants being the of Ammenti m the Dominion Canada and the government of province of Quebec of the one and the government of newfound and of the dispute involving a question concerning tre of who is to adjudicate in future questions of this kind assuredly the supreme court of Canada cannot do so since Canada is a what is Fol Lowed when a dispute involves a civil action let a Canadian the French or belgian government Are advocating a policy mileage operated tons freight moved acreage under 1919 we Thi Kindol Greene of Canada limited 285 Beaver Hill average total j Good overseas the judge Wlton our these think interesting to learn what your of construction Bev without i agree the privy great Britain herself would to seek the arbitration of the president of the or Itoe Rother chief far More upon frequently than is Oramous surely canadians would to mixe Bank do posits 1911 value of waste paper from the number of inquiries reaching the commission of indicates an increasing inter stud the saving of waste schools Are taking up the in some a Friendly rivalry the school children t has resulted in much larger Quantity being the of have us during sold Over 60 great interest is taken children i news method of obtaining school your capital stays at Home and its interest is paid to Manitoba citizens instead of in the East or in other countries when you Deposit your savings in this every account build greater better improved1 greater Mani open an account in your own inst deposits at ant Gharam Tbod by the of is Bethe uti Uzal ;