Winnipeg Free Press

Winnipeg Free Press {Newspaper} - 1981-05-06,Winnipeg, Manitoba Vin Peg free press wednesday May 6, 1981 9 Appeal court notes trial errors but upholds rape verdict by Pamela Faye Ian Llie Manitoba court of Appeal has unanimously dismissed an Appeal by women who were sentenced to Gaur years in prison last october on rape arid Gross Iii decency charges stemming Fern i iil7fi ii i u no with a prostitute. A a written ruling or Justice j. 1. O Sullivan sgt id that despite some errors by Law made by Queens Bench trial judge or. Justice a Scott Wright the errors did not cause any a substantial wrong or miscarriage of Saul Edward Engel 26. And David Bejamin Friedman 27. Were found guilty by judge Wright in september 1980. The two men had fled to Israel before they were to stand trial in �o977, but won new radiated last summer. Noting Al Friedman a lawyer Greg Brodsky had argued that the identification of his Cilenzi at he police station when arrested was so defective that it was unreliable judge o Sullivan said he agreed the line up was a a he said judge Wright erred when he f / 3 Days Only buying used furs Uri Tilv Al la a ill a Iii Ijar a ii Trust o sorry use a fut Coal or Jenckel a. A. Age to Psi inn Lar 11 Yuu Liun t Modr it. In especially Nosic Fol Mink. For. Nac Coor Nilly is or --5 in i a Quot l t f p furs by tag your garment id Winnipeg inn 2 Lombard place amp 957-1350 Hay 5. 6. 7 Tiki hrs 11 . S . In Btry o m Runl-.�?o�. Pet Stop 44 Sta Acona Street to alb Naar Louis a Bridge pm. 667-5358 8 pkg Purina dog Chow. .7.49 8 pkg Tuffyas High protein heal. 7.39 1 pkg Purina meow mix.1.69 425 g Pussy a boots beef amp kidney 2/75 one Day Only May 9, 198t limited quantities said that none of the i. _ the line up appeared different in dress from rhe accused. A in my opinion no weight should have been Given to it Quot he added. As Well. Judge o Sullivan said he agreed with the defence counsel that it was an error on the part of the trial judge to hold that the flight of the accused to Israel was corroborative of the Story. Quot i agree the flight under the circumstances was equivocal certainly in the Case of agree on error judge o Sullivan agreed funner with Harry Walsh lawyer for eng i who argued that it was an error to allow the Crown to cite evidence that Engel had told police he knew nothing about the incident. Brodsky argued that i was also an error to admit in evidence the fact Thal Freidman stood mute when confronted with the Alle Gainons. A after caution Mere silence or a refusal to say anything when confronted with allegations by a policeman is . A judge of Ssllivan said the convictions depend entirely on the credibility of the Conidia infant an admitted prostitute. Judge Wright said the fact the 25-Ycar-old woman was a prostitute did not enter into his be relict. Reviewing the evidence of the complainant. Judge o Sullivan said she was offered a ride Home in Engel s car but was never taken there. Instead she was raped by both accused. She said she consented because she was afraid of ilium. Judge of Sullivan said he agreed with the trial judge in admitting the com plan ans evidence. A Eimoce lawyers had argued that the complain Atil did not complain about the rape soon enough. Judge of Sullivan said he did agree with the defence counsel that her statement saying she did not wish to proceed with charges was Impo Nant. Province takes officers Case to supreme court sae Manji Oha Pitt onion general s department has filed a notice of Appeal to Iii the supreme court of Canada Challon Gitig the recent acquittal of two Winnipeg police officers on a joint charge of assault. Constables Ronald Albert Chambers and Lawrence Ernest Obirek have been convicted of the charge he two different provi Jacial court judges. However after tie first conviction the Appeal in dirt ordered a Aew trial and after the second Cocivi clan the Appeal coun overturned the ruling and acquitted the pair. The mice of i peal filed with he a Gist Arof the supreme court in Ottawa last week contends the Appeal court a erred in Law and misconstrued its Power Ander the criminal code of Canada. Chambers and Obirek were charged with assaulting robbery suspect Carlo Filbert Macario on feb. 27,1s79. At the fort carry police station. The pair were convicted by judge Mike Baryluk and sentenced to three months in jail but the Appeal court ordered a new trial. They were subsequently convicted again by chief provincial judge Harold Gyles. In a split decision rendered on april 9, the Appeal court ruled there were a serious inconsistencies and disc Repen cies in the evidence and the Crown had not proved its Case beyond a reasonable doubt. Following the court s decision the two constables were reinstated to the police Force after having been suspended for a total of 16 months. Dealerships location overstocked Sii e High s Terest costs we intend to a Bice a Tir inventor to an All time Low Chrysler Plymouth Dodge trucks a a a Jeom Panyar at amp minds car of me yeah k cars 1931 reliant 2 or. A , rtufo., bet Ali a lec. Hts a a. R Vii now. We a amps. C Fri get who or. Deluse slice Reg who in Sijo he out St. Sis 1981 reliant 4 or. ? 2 tie. Auto. Fled Tny by innit Fogt a Iid h Vainuu . A ii. St. #1593 1981 reliant Wagon 2-3 in. 4 ii in. I buy Mirtyl Btu Ncik. Vav w Liri a my i j St sr1-b99 a j t9b1 d50 , see he Ciu Lucid Troi. A Ufi. A or fluto. A Cletru. To it. . Csc Biji Ikuls. Spedrl slower no we0 Dokr color ,.ti.s. Ca air Rte Lbrown Kerf def p. U Ito a a front Elton of a siiri St. Lil so i9s1 do . 7499 7599 7777 n am jeep Renault i Sefl bit orca Tifi of a or. I g of rec a Eiko Gera Orl we. 8 Sooko whl�., brawn lid a a 5999 8199 9999 19b1 Lebaron 4 or. B2 5l3 Enri. Aula. F. So Corina p soak a. Biro Civ. Caara Lier. Of to. Or. Winus a. End a Cater. A no a Iowa tires Tuuu mid Vii l Tup. Stripes up arc. St. �104 a Vav beat the pump 9399 6499 6399 9399 8899 6699 10,799. At i Milio 1931 Colt 3 by. Mitis -1 Liri s Al Bik Vnye 0 Rir-,.5. St. Ill-557 1981 Caravelle 2 or i ii Airo. P sri a p . C3v film in Aso i try. In Liucy hts or. Wiolinv., by oct he Ilist. Jjlia ii.-. H sism cd org. We ticks Silver Mlej. Ii i ,. Fire Gnu. Spans a 1331 Lebaron a i. A 13i .10 Init i i a a air cd Cli a i Alijio -. �1-263 a i9s1 Caravelle so .�3 j Iii., a Titi Vinyl Bunch. £00 Asp. Re rate a a aaa kor or. Ena hmm i. A Kadio. He. Sun. Wrt tire. I. R 10,999 Croo . Or. Floor de ii Llor. Roof rach St. 1981 Cordoba 2 or. I. i a in in to s�1 Cir it re Lar. i tin a Cal a. �.-mo�. A Mirror. £1. C it if Vikor a i i Viv a a clock h�-.=1, a Tvr 3ki sri Muci in a i of Scia Tfir Vinyl Tor in Len 0. pm cd r a a Al i of to Volt Iri it Chi i a .5p,it,�?~, Oticia i. Rtiz St. 1,377 1981 Cordoba 2 or. A a a wed p Btu he a a to . Tim �t., t in rom Tifi a of . £1l0i k i .iie.-/, a i n a a Covi it in a birr it a i a re a a Diirr ,. T . moni.-. In Wuhu l us it Jamu what a to. =1 19b1 Cordoba 2 or. A i 7 in. P or the Imit. my. A but . , hid. I. Vinci cd Fiock am m.�. To 1981 horizon miser 5 000ft 1 f Uro in Rah Auto. Csc custom High Baia. -130 Asp i Saffery. Ella . Hurt. H. Window. Raar i Niichi is incr eng a Cote it ram radio. Stance Sirij wow a jew Ciger Fttie Ligi iter Tiht ttl-570 19s1 horizon 5 or. I 7 Lily a a spa Lila pkaa., bucket Vinyl Seal. Elec hta r a Milia Block Buchter. A Diu. We Ririe Bik ill dts p Anslom Inlet my pkgc., Cigar. Liable. Span St. St i 19s1 horizon 5 or. I Lim. To. Lite pkg. Csc Eju cots. 430 amp but dry. Etc i Ltd h a endow Bloth Heater radio. Tires a Oik. Mid custom exl Arlof Cir jul dior Swerc Sih i�ms8 1331 horizon tc3 j 2 lire aul Cansolia. Civ Bucke. -1 to amp Battery. Daily re Mold Klir Rai. Exec. Had h. Vii new. 6toi i Heater. Am radio single or Ilia kor v.v/. Term a Ite. Strip i. Tur it re Jau co of. La a a. Spare. Chiju car Pirl. I Lily Minoi. Sih 19b1 horizon tc3 1 7 . 4 Sci. Lilo Page. Slot. Hoo r wrv3ow. Block radio. Tro amp. Spare file. »1-209 1981 b2sq Wagon tone . Auto. S 8. Lehi pkg. h a. Air Pofi acc a. Am pm ca5s#e. Cruise. Till h pm it. Law Morin mirrors us amp. Bol Lelet r Mil. Us Cal. Intr 03 arrid Alcuin air. Burn or Hicri Cigar a vhf. F let or sign roof Psi Maui 1-505 1981 Dodge d15d Auto. A. 6399 6899 7399 7777 7499. . Bisck Henri. Glju���., . 15,989 7999 8899 6 Crim b250 Van Lulea f lure. It. 6j and air a tar. it r. s Dick Hir. Bucko sl-b0� 1981 ram Charger Allie Hajj Hii iils. Smisl Lizur . Cn.is-. To i. A Ltd o. 3�� cd till p amp 0 Toni up int. Royals a pkg. If Cund Hoh by a. Clot i Sira l Ciji ii is. I a mount hiff�ff., by ritmoe.5l.nk Dilt he yes. Sold pm if. Sun trip �15,1 clock. Suns Roun plays p d Al fun Hii Jit si-.345 1980 Cherokee 2 or. 1 Only i Chip Stef rung. W. . A win Dow do lost Colo chm ale Gap. Plus Mere. Eth. Ai&-162 13s1 spirit 2 or. Sedan uyi., air to p Gli Misiti Nacir of Lnda to stir i la into cd tire i i. . Rii Lic Sik. S1-1q1 1981 spirit 2 or lift Back .Vi. Al it in. P. Sec i Iris h. Vhf nov. Of afros. Re of six a cilia. A St. 1-128 19b1 Renault deluxe r18 so a i Cyl ,. . I Iii i a i Ului. Re . Much Moruk. Jn-1 h 1981 Renault r18 h or. Sedan $ "1 Cyl. Ajo Palijo inure More Sik. J1-115 1981 r5 gel 4 or. 4 Fly. 4 spd., edited to. R. Amdo Yew. Radio plus Moch Mph a. St. Sri Jit 1981 All new jeep scrambler 6 cv�?Tl., p in. . Fittl time 4 Vii cd. . I 205 1981 Cherokee chief 2 or. Fit a Quot a �?o11,1 Page p. Ell h. Wiki of. Clotill sub. Tilt Sliwin p. Pm a for till cold climate Cirp. Poo Flack Brusini ?0b Siki #1 1981 Eagle 2 or. 1 Chi. 5 so hear with dds Oslo Cal. Fli Aio. Cold Chaio gip. Sik. 1981 Eagle sx4 4 by4 spa. Elee hid. H. Window. Radio cold climate Gap. Sik. Ffl.125 a 1981 jeep cj5 renegade it Chi.1 up i. Page. P. St Orin p. Or secs. I1.1�oi1l1, tilt steer Jug soft lop plus More St. #t1-12n 1931 Concord 2 or. Do. .vi, my a p s,.,,,. Ski ,?,.,r. A w Alfh h a Tab. P i la a Bihar Tirikki n w Sli Timnui ill. Gutti. pm he Ruo he ,o,.c Mon finer i col j . To or i i i sikh a my a 1381 jeep a ton pick do 6 pirt., Dulo. P. . P brakes. Coia a Lumalo gun julus i jct much Morii Sik. ?1.170 1981 jeepcj7 e Cyl. A spa. P Slid Raj p. By Rikus hard top cold climate Gap. Plus Muich More St. »1-179 1981 Concord 4 or. Do. 6 Chi. Aito., p a to Yenry a. R. Window a Frost Padio cock a climate to up. Sik. #1.12-1 1981 Eagle 4 or. Al. U Chi. Ault. P to to p. Bari or Ottiar a inflow det Rosl . Gap Sik. »1�?T127 12,399 6999 7899 9799 8399 9699 10,399 7799 9499 15,555 monday thursday till 9 30 Friday amp saturday till 5 30 we Yaj Lluver pay for your Trade 1905 main St. Ale ends May 9/81 339-20t1 la Canadian transport Corii Mission Westton Ulvi Siau notice of Public hearing commission Cati Adienne Des transports Niv Isje a de l guest Avis d audience Lique in the matter of anew ii in a lion of fac following posse a i Cojei train a a Ivimey for thu Pur poses of determining Wyeth amp a they should a amp nil Elaine in or . In or in put in. Winnie co Thomoson Churchill a mins no a. 90. Ai. His a a Bawdy ii Church it ill. Mixed Eairs nos. &94. 29n Ihn per Lynn i Nike. A Iii Dirgins nos. 290. Lillis nos. 49467 7 i 49457 82 i whereas. As an integral inn of is Revheim arid a a in a it Iliia lion program. Thyl Raik Vay t Ransport Cion Clitee the Ca Nav Ian transport commission wih hold linear figs on the above Man Lignori Phi Rongner trains Fiji flu Fern in Ord i Lodl tar Riino the in Drc its and co Cortis of the our ii take notice that q Sublie hearing Oti lib above Mun Tiona int la a will be held Al Thi following a ails and i act a 0a1e monday. 1000 . My 25. 9bi la Lund. 25 mini 198i Luh de l Avail i Fly thursday. To 00 . May 2h, 198i Jeudi. ?0 thai l 9a 1 la a de i go nil Liidi monday. 10 00 . July �0. 19�oi la Iun ref. 2 Jii Illel i9ai Loh de 1 Avint Milid it Ilea Day. us .1 m. Jul of 21. 981 be Verdi. 21 Juillet 1981 la a Rio thursday 10 00 . July 23. 1981 i e Velidi 2 3 Iii Len ip8i Loh Rio Avant it Rhodi or trons Pinr info to Rita find for hearing play submit their View in Rilin i by Maii Inq Sam i no Leasi Len Flo Clivy prior to Riata of Henring to Sech to Iii i Eslyn of Visioni canal Iii to an amp Worl ?5ion suite 415. Fisc Iorii building 10<-s2nd Street Easi sysk Loon. Yaskal Chowan Vilh copy to or l. W. Hail Assil no St retry it incl a Horny via Rii i it Hikida inc Tihoi Mcquil Coll Vic to Nurial. Quebec end 1 or. S a Cir tin Jubel Sci Nodi in it anal Raik Vivis p o to 8100. Dialion a a Montreal. Oje Bec h in 3n4 All portions a Sci wifi to 00 to Nav pro ant in fair views on Aboia mentioned malted during i if Honing any Pirty with my of give to uni Dyrine or \0 Dudt ibs to Iii conv in Gassior it in Trench Triay Dos j ind the Corri Mission upon Noth by Thi. Pirly of his of bet into Nihon a do so. Will a ran Rifi Lor the a fish Liran Slaton services which can be provided under Ispir it circumstances Dato thu. 29fh Day of april Lilbia store Lav Fri o vision candid Len a r,in.�- Iori commission St fun 15. Ltd Curli Bui icing îOi-22nd str a Al Eric a Wiiki Itoyo. Gasky ii Bewz a to l g6&-5302 074-2690 of a relative a i j a to do Don a or vices Fly Bains de Voytal uis suivant in vue de determiner s �i5 Dolver Elro Moniri Zerfus of abandon no son engr ice Auen Partie Enbe him. Trains nos 90. 91. 92. 93 Wabowden Churchill trains t1?s nos 294. 296 to Pas Lynn Lake. Ira rns Miles Lios 290. 291. Dossiers nor. 494.111.74 49467 ,b7 494d7.s2 attend que. Of Orrne Faisant partier Rio son pro Gre a lib a de revise of eld i Ra-1>onaljsaiion a comity Des transports parch Ryttin de 1er de if Nan noir nne Des a ran sports lib Naira de a udi princes relatives a i Ai Faire Sun Ronen Tonnee Fin Doc on Nahro i inter i Dup Bic Avis est Dot be que Des Ati die Ces obliques rela Ilves a la Alfaire summent Fortee Aurant lieu Auk end oits it dates Sui vents Loc Atiah Androit address Odresse the pcs Manitoba Council Cham ers o Edwards avens amp Manitoba Cut in boo Hall la Verendrye Street Thompson mar to bad 10 be deter Birned at a Lafor Dart of etre determine plus lard Iii Jim Iwan Toha to be on Ormine Ai d a Yler dais a etre debtor mine plus Tard Wynn per Yani Loba to be det Arnii Ted at a later Dale a Etc plus lard Les personnel Quine pour ont asst St a a to Faience Devrint pro Ridnor fours com mfg it Arras Pat a Crit a coins Aii 10 hours Nivani la Date Rie l Auric Erx a. In Les Laisant Par vein flu Sec hts to division de l driest con Mission Canad Urne Des transports suite <1 15. Federal building Ini-?2e nue est so a Saloon say Kut Chewan ave Une Copie l. Tv1 had a Fec Zaire Adjoint i Avoca i via is i Canna inc. La vol. Rue a a Colonie Mcgill Montreal que ii us 7i m s a Calm a oct aupry a de co ii miss tin chem in de 1er Nalio Nau do c3nad< p. 8100. Succur Sale a Quot Montry Al Quebec h3c 3n4 t Jle Peronne quite Desre part turn per seller son Point de Vlf a sur Allaire sus Mcne Ion Noii Pendant i and nce Les parties it Les inter tenants Dot sir eur Are Des Doc agents. De Tom Pugner a d in Lyt Venir it i an la commit by on in trance is Peugent the Taire it la commission Lor Squy Avsec Par cd the parity de son de la Faire retire a la disposal Hon Dij Celle i Les amp or vines d qui Pouf front Etro Tournis in Raison desc a con Lance amp Date eur 29ieme Oor d Avril i9bl. Llhee a Ijar in and div Siclyn de f Ckik Fth commission Canadien nth Dps transports suite 415, Federal build my -2ie Rue i it St or Skalo amp i Saskatchewan Tif <30bi �o65-5202 Tele �/4-2by3 Saites i Partridge 338-7071 relax Bright informative Reading daily plus listings Lor radio to and what s on around town Winnipeg free press Home delivery957-0550 ;