Winnipeg Free Press

Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - June 25, 2012, Winnipeg, Manitoba C M Y K PAGE A6 O TTAWA - Green Party leader Elizabeth May held a quiz last week for any MPs willing to prove they'd actually read all of the 425- page omnibus budget bill in its entirety. May was hoping to prove the trained- seal theory among the government backbenchers, many of whom she accused of voting on measures they couldn't possibly have actually read. It is not fair to believe that just because no government MPs showed up, that it proves none of them actually read the bill. While some government backbenchers likely didn't read the bill from cover to cover, it's just as likely some MPs on the opposition side also missed a clause or two or 20. Regardless of how well he thought they would fare, there was almost more of a chance Prime Minister Stephen Harper would compliment Pierre Trudeau that day than allow one of his MPs to take May's bait. But that in and of itself, however, makes May's point. The party politics in Ottawa are such that MPs have almost no independence from their party leaders. Even cabinet ministers are on such short leashes that many appear authorized to do nothing but deliver talking points prepared by the PMO. Backbenchers vote how and when told, and don't speak out against party policy at almost any time. It is particularly telling that there was one MP who showed up for the quiz. Bruce Hyer, a Thunder Bay- area MP formerly of the NDP caucus, took and aced the 15- minute test. He is also one of the few Independents in the House of Commons, able to think, act and vote without fear or favour from a party apparatus. Hyer left the NDP earlier this year after he was punished for voting in favour of the government's legislation to eliminate the long- gun registry. Now he's on a mission to bring some independence back to his fellow MPs. Since becoming an Independent, Hyer has increased his national profile significantly. He can ask his own questions in question period, participate in news conferences on any topic and weigh in on matters that previously would have been reserved for the party critics. Although he doesn't get to sit on any committees, Hyer can still introduce amendments to bills at third reading. All in all, he said, the last few months as an Independent have been the best of his nearly four years on the Hill so far. " I feel far more effective as an Independent MP," Hyer said. Hyer says at least half a dozen MPs from all other parties have bought him " a beer or a coffee" in order to pick his brain about the benefits of being an Independent. Hyer is making freedom for backbench MPs a calling card of his time as an MP. He has introduced several motions and bills thus far on the subject, including one to allow MPs from different parties to co- sponsor private member's bills. That way, he said, private member's bills would be less likely to be seen as partisan business and could be debated openly. He has another motion asking to randomly assign seats in the House of Commons rather than having all MPs from the same party sit together " like hockey teams." Hyer's thought is that MPs who get to know each other better are less likely to hurl insults across the floor and more likely to maybe consider motions and bills and ideas from their opponents. He also has a motion to change the requirement for party leaders to sign the nomination papers of all candidates running for their party. Hyer said party leaders use those nomination signatures as leverage to get MPs to toe the party line at all times. A threat that if he didn't vote with the NDP on the gun registry would risk his future nomination was the last straw for Hyer before he quit the NDP in protest. Hyer said one of the downsides of not being in a party is not having access to the party research bureau or getting cheat sheets reminding what way to vote on certain complicated clauses in bills. But that often means MPs don't actually have to read all of the legislation they are voting on. " It really shouldn't be that way," he said. One can only wonder what kind of stimulating debate and interesting ideas Parliament might come up with if more MPs were able to think and vote for their constituents, and if more than just the PMO and the official opposition leader were calling the shots. mia. rabson@ freepress. mb. ca A 6 MONDAY, JUNE 25, 2012 CANADA winnipegfreepress. com Nissan ads with the Layar logo come to life with your iOS/ Android device. The Layar app available for both iPhone/ iPad and Android. Try this! View this page with Layar Download the Layar app Launch the app Hover & tap your device over the Layar- enabled page Wait for floating buttons to appear to unlock exclusive hidden content Device Requirements iOS / Android Wi- Fi / 3G / LTE GPS enabled 1 3 2 4 No purchase necessary. Contest open to legal residents of Canada. Entrants must be over the age of majority in their province or territory. Odds of winning depend on the number of entries received. Enter online at www. canada. com/ contests/ Nissan ( the " Contest Website") or by using the Layar App to view the Nissan print advertisement published in Postmedia Newspapers during the Contest period. Limit of one ( 1) Canada. com Entry and one ( 1) Layar Entry per person per day during the Contest Period. Winner must correctly answer a time- limited skill- testing question. Contest starts June 13, 2012 and ends July 12, 2012. Secondary Prize Winners will be selected on June 20, 2012, June 27, 2012, July 4, 2012, and July 13, 2012 in Toronto, Ontario. Grand Prize Winner will be selected on July 13, 2012 in Toronto, Ontario. There is one ( 1) Grand Prize of Three Thousand Dollars ( CDN $ 3,000.00) in cash and four ( 4) Secondary Prizes of Five Hundred Dollars ( CDN $ 500.00) in cash available to be won. Full Contest Rules can be found at the Contest Website. THE YEAR OF CONTEST ENTER NOW WITH LAYAR OR ONLINE AT CANADA. COM/ NISSAN Enter for a chance to WIN a weekly draw of $ 500 or the grand prize of $ 3000 . Manufacturer's warranty . 30- day/ 2500 km no- hassle exchange privilege . 150+ point inspections . 24- hour roadside assistance 2400 McPHILLIPS ST CREDIT CONCERNS / GET PRE- APPROVED CALL 1- 888- 717- 2855 SALES HOTLINE ( 204) 633- 8833 All pre- owned prices and payments are bi- weekly, plus taxes, $ 2000 down or equivalent trade. 7.99% OAC. * 84 ** 72 *** 60 mths. Example: 2011 Chev Impala $ 14,525 less $ 2000 trade is $ 12,525 or $ 94 b/ w 84 mos. 7.99% OAC. * See dealer for details. shop @ jimgauthiergmc. com on l l i ine 2011 CHEVY IMPALA LT 4 DR. SAVE UP TO 50% 3.5L, V6, A. T., air cond., cruise, tilt, P/ W, P/ L, P/ M, power seat, keyless entry Power seat, remote start, Bluetooth, alloy wheels and more. Stk. # P4172 WAS $ 30,155 ON SALE AS LOW AS 2.4L 170 HP eng, 4 cyl, flex fuel, 48 MPG, 6 spd auto trans, air, cruise, PW, PL, PM, 6 way pwr dr seat, 17" Alum whls, Onstar, much more. Stk. # A4960 WAS $ 29,805 NOW AS LOW AS l, fl fu el M PG 2011 CHEVY MALIBU LT PLATINUM EDITION Choose from 16 Choose from 3 FREE CAR PROOF ON EVERY USED VEHICLE GUARANTEED CREDIT APPROVAL! OUR LOWEST PRICES OF THE YEAR! S U M M E R H A S A R RI V E D F OR O U R ANNUAL SUMMER SELLDOWN! GAUTHIER GMC USED SUPERCENTRE $ 14 , 500 OR $ 108 BW.* $ 12 , 525 OR $ 94 BW.* $ 115 , 997 OR $ 119 BW.* $ 5 , 988 * * $ 7 , 380 OR $ 64 BW.** $ 1 19 9 , , 8 85 50 OR $ 146 BW.* 4 cyl., rated at 48 MPG, auto trans, fully loaded, power group, cruise, heated seats & much more. Stk. # P4027 4.3 V6, AT, air conditioning, AM/ FM/ CD and more. Only 93,000 kms. Stk. # T12148A 2 dr's and 4 dr's, 4 cyl., AT, air, AM/ FM/ CD and more. Stk. # P4051 6 cyl, fully loaded incl. quad seating, dual air and heat. Stk. # P4127 Choose from 6 Choose from 5 Choose from 5 WAS $ 21,995 NOW AS LOW AS WAS $ 9,995 NOW WAS $ 12,995 NOW AS LOW AS WAS $ 24,995 NOW AS LOW AS yl. at d t to tra 2011 SONATA GL 4 DR. V6 AT ai nditioni nd 2003 GMC SONOMA SLS EXT CAB 2WD nd d r' yl ir 2009 CHEV COBALT/ PONTIAC G5 l, l de d in cl ad ti 2012 DODGE GRAND CARAVAN SXT STO N GO WAS $ 26,995 NOW WAS $ 22,995 NOW WAS $ 34,995 NOW WAS $ 36,995 NOW WAS $ 19,995 NOW WAS $ 14,995 NOW WAS $ 34,900 NOW WAS $ 37,995 NOW $ 2 23 , 988 OR $ 2 229 BW. *** $ 18 , , 988 OR $ 183 BW. *** $ 3 32 , 8 888 OR $ 2 240 BW. * $ 3 30 , 988 OR $ 2 227 BW. ** $ 15 , 988 OR $ 155 BW. *** $ 11 , 500 OR $ 112 BW. *** $ 3 32 , 988 OR $ 3 314 BW. *** $ 2 27 , 8 888 OR $ 2 298 BW. *** 6.1L V8, AT, fully loaded, power moonroof. Only 4,200 ( not a misprint) original kms. Perfect! Stk. # P5565B SLE, 5.3L V8, A. T. and fully loaded. Real nice! Stk. # T12257A 5.7L V8, TRD off road pkg and fully loaded incl power moonroof. Only 40,000 kms. Stk. # T12270A 6 cyl, auto & fully loaded. Only 15,000 kms. Fun in the sun V8, AT, fully loaded, heated leather seats, power moonroof. Immaculate! Stk. # P4139A V6, A. T. and fully loaded. Only 67,000 kms. Stk. # T12112B LTZ, 6.6L Duramax diesel. Fully loaded incl p. moonroof, leather, nav, DVD & shell cap. Mint truck. Stk. # T12378A The Real Hummer, fully loaded incl power moonroof, leather, DVD & much more. Only 64,000 kms on this local vehicle. A must see Stk. # P5565A 2006 DODGE CHARGER SRT8 2007 GMC SIERRA EXT CAB 4X4 2010 TOYOTA TUNDRA CREW MAX 4X4 loaded 2012 JEEP WRANGLER UNLIMITED 4X4 2006 AVALANCHE LT 4X4 2007 TORRENT FWD 2007 SILVERADO 2500 HD CREW CAB 4X4 Hummer 2006 HUMMER H2 4X4 SECOND GENERATION CVT TRANSMISSION . NISSAN ALTIMA An MP who can think for himself Thunder Bay MP Bruce Hyer can vote ( and think) freely in the House of Commons. As a result, he's enjoying a greater national profile MIA RABSON SEAN KILPATRICK / THE CANADIAN PRESS A_ 08_ Jun- 25- 12_ FP_ 01. indd A6 6/ 24/ 12 10: 19: 12 PM ;