Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - June 28, 2012, Winnipeg, Manitoba
C M Y K PAGE B4
We understand
having the right people
makes a difference.
Weunderstand
Find a lawyer that's right for you.
Visit pitblado. com
Welcome to the firm Jason Bryk and
Leith Robertson!
While each of these individuals has exceptional
skills and a clear passion for the law, they are
most importantly a terrific fit for our Firm in both
personality and style.
The Partners at Pitblado understand that people
choose lawyers they know, like and trust. As a result,
our daily focus is on our values, our people and the
way we do business for our clients. We are pleased
and proud to congratulate both of these men on their
recent accomplishment!
Pitblado Law is pleased
to announce that these
talented lawyers were
recently called to the Bar.
BUSINESS EDITOR: STEVE PONA 697- 7264 business@ freepress. mb. ca I MARKET DETAILS B6,7 I winnipegfreepress. com
THURSDAY, JUNE 28, 2012
B 4
I NNOVATE Manitoba, along with the national organization
Startup Canada, met about 300 entrepreneurs and supporters
over the last couple of weeks in Winnipeg and Brandon.
The point of the activity was to celebrate and encourage
entrepreneurship.
Entrepreneurs would probably prefer if you could just send
money.
That's right. Access to capital continues to be a critical problem.
As one technology- industry specialist said, encouraging the
bootstrapping of businesses into success is one thing, but eventually
some capital is required.
There is an acute awareness of the issue in the community
and a mobilization of energies is underway.
The Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce is not likely to turn the
city into a Silicon Valley of the north, but it has a fairly wellheeled
task force putting the final touches on a draft policy on
venture capital.
" People talk about the deals being done in other provinces
and it is just not happening here as much as it should be," said
Chuck Davidson, vice- president policy at the Winnipeg Chamber
of Commerce. " There is an increased awareness of the
importance on the issue of capital right now."
If innovation and the growth in homegrown enterprises are
crucial to the ongoing health of the economy, then such activity
needs to be supported, one way or another.
More investment capital might not have directly saved the
National Research Council's Institute for Biodiagnostics that's
closing down and leaving about 60 wellpaid
researchers and scientists out of
work.
But who knows what its fate would
have been if more companies emanating
out of the research done at the NRC
could have been formed and funded and
grown into sustainable enterprises.
" We do need a bank for technology
companies in our community. That's a
statement of fact," said Harry Schulz, a
veteran business development player in
the medical technology field in Winnipeg.
Schulz is a managing director of Linn Grove Ventures, an
American/ Canadian fund that's raising $ 125 million to invest in
agribusiness technology companies in the Red River corridor.
" It is important for our infrastructure, our ecosystem, for
innovation, that we have some leadership in the community to
enable that to happen," he said.
So the chamber is out there marshalling interested parties
and trying to present a model that will work in the province.
The consensus is that provincial money is needed to fund the
super- high- risk idea- to- prototype period, but not for later stages
- from $ 250,000 to $ 5 million and beyond.
Gary Brownstone, CEO of The Eureka Project, the business
incubation centre at the U of M's Smartpark, is also trying to
formalize a fund concept he has that includes marrying capital
and management at the earliest stages of a company's formation.
He realizes that during these uncertain economic times no
one is throwing extra money at anything. And since the laboursponsored-
fund debacle of a decade ago, the provincial government
maintains a fairly conservative attitude about investing in
a sector that has at least a 70 per cent failure rate at the best of
times.
" There is a public image risk," Brownstone said. " Who wants
to be seen squandering public money in difficult economic
times."
But if this stuff were easy we'd all be rich.
The province launched Commercialization Support for
Business Program Manitoba last year and there are plenty of
suggestions as to how it can be tinkered with to better aid early
stage companies. Also, some are pitching a way to broaden the
Community Enterprise Development Tax Credit to include tax
credits for approved funds as well as individual investors.
The chamber is also revisiting the whole issue of figuring out
some palatable way to get Manitoba public sector pension funds
to put more money back into the province.
It's important work that continues to demand serious effort.
martin. cash@ freepress. mb. ca
MONTREAL - After failing to attract
buyers for its airframe business, insolvent
aircraft maintenance firm Aveos
Fleet Performance is seeking court
approval today to break up and sell the
unit's assets to several buyers for $ 10.8
million, says the monitor overseeing
the company's dismantling.
The prospective buyers include three
Canadian firms, two U. S.- based companies
and one liquidator.
The purchase prices paid by the companies
weren't disclosed in case Aveos
has to return to the market if the transactions
don't close.
No single buyer was found to restart
the airframe unit's operations because
its business model in Canada " has a
limited role in a global context" and is
not globally competitive, the monitor's
report says.
The buyers include Avianor Inc.
based in Mirabel, Que., Avmax Aviation
Services Inc. of Calgary and
Discovery Air Technical, a subsidiary
of Yellowknife- based Discovery Air
( TSX: DA. A).
Premier Aviation Overhaul Center
of New York, which has an operation
in Trois- Rivi�res, Que., and Illinoisbased
Aircraft Services Inc. will also
acquire parts of the business.
Liquidator Maynards Industries Ltd.
will buy several lots of equipment it
will sell by private sale or at public
auction in September before Aveos
plans to vacate Air Canada hangars in
Montreal, Winnipeg and Vancouver.
Work on repairing and overhauling
airframes has increasingly gone to lowcost
operations in Asia, Latin America
and elsewhere.
Consequently, the assets were offered
in smaller " digestible" lots so
that Canadian maintenance, repair and
overhaul ( MRO) operators could have
an opportunity equal to that of a global
buyer to acquire parts of the business.
" The result is that most of the strategic
asset buyers under the transactions
which are being recommended
for approval are MROs operating in
Canada who intend to expand their current
service offerings or develop new
lines of service in Canada, utilizing
these specific assets," said Jonathan
Solursh, chief restructuring officer at
Aveos.
The airframe unit received 22 bids
for its various parts, including 17 from
strategic purchasers and five from liquidators,
but none that wanted to keep
the business together.
The Aveos airframe business employed
about 1,500 of the company's
2,600 workers before it closed operations
in March and obtained protection
from creditors under the Companies'
Creditors Arrangement Act.
Monitor FTI Consulting said the
sales process for the engine business
has been extended to a July 26 court
hearing. The delay will give prospective
buyers additional time to " address
and resolve various issues, including
exhausting all options to determine if
there is the possibility of a going concern
or modified going concern solution."
Air Canada ( TSX: AC. B) and Aveos
have signed a new exclusive engine
repair contract through 2017, provided
the purchaser of the business is one of
five deemed acceptable by the airline
in terms of operational requirements.
Canada's largest carrier also agreed
to conduct a request for proposals for
work on about 1,000 component parts
serviced by Aveos. Work on the fiveto
10- year contract must be done at
Aveos's facility. The sale of the landing
gear assets have also been deferred.
" There are multiple suitors for the
Component Maintenance business who
are engaged in meaningful discussions
with the company, the union and other
stakeholders," the monitor said.
- The Canadian Press
T HE union representing Via Rail employees
in Winnipeg said they were
" blindsided" by cuts announced by
the government- owned passenger rail service
on Wednesday.
" The union was totally blindsided on this.
We were given no notice," said Dave Kissack,
Canadian Auto Workers' union representative
in Winnipeg, adding federal government
cuts backed Via into a financial
corner.
Via Rail expects to cut 200 unionized jobs
or about nine per cent of its workforce, and
will reduce services across the country,
Via Rail CEO Marc Laliberte said in the
city. Thirty- eight jobs will be cut in Winnipeg,
but Kissack said more than 600 jobs
in Western Canada could be affected.
" It's going to have an impact on over 600
people in Western Canada one way or another
due to displacements and bumping, so
we have to do what we can to mitigate the
impact of that," said Kissack, adding protecting
employees' seniority so they aren't
moved to lower- level jobs is a priority.
Although the move comes in the wake of
the federal government's March budget,
which cut $ 41 million in subsidies to Via
over three years, Via insists the trip reductions
and job losses are driven by weak offseason
demand.
But Jennifer Brown, president of CAW
Local 4005, said demand is up 7.8 per cent
since last year and nearly 25 per cent in the
peak season.
" So where they're getting their numbers
, we don't know. I work on board and from
January my trains have been sold out," she
said.
Kissack said Winnipeggers will see an
impact as Via tries to restructure.
" Ninety per cent of ( Via employees) in
Western Canada work out of Winnipeg and
there's going to be a significant financial
impact on the people of this city," he said.
Via workers said they are worried about
the ripple effects of the cuts, regardless of
whether they keep their jobs.
" Why does it seem that the people who
always pay the price are the people who
are holding this company together?" said
a Winnipeg Via Rail employee, who didn't
want to be named to protect his job.
Another Winnipeg employee, who's
worked for Via for over two decades, said
while he is not concerned he will be laid
off, he's worried he'll be moved to a much
lower position.
" It's very discouraging to take those
steps forward and then be thrown back five
steps," he said.
He added if his job was moved to a different
city, he would have no option but to quit
to keep his family in Winnipeg.
Via said it will not cut any whole routes
and it is working to expand track capacity
on the busy Montreal- Toronto corridor.
The service adjustments will be rolled out
between July and the end of October.
Trip frequencies are being cut on some
of the big routes.
In the west, The Canadian - a Toronto
to Vancouver route - will be reduced from
three to two round trips a week in the offseason
( October to April). Service during
peak season will remain at three trips a
week.
There will also be reductions in southwestern
Ontario, where GO Transit and
other services are available to commuters.
London, Aldershot, Kitchener, Niagara
Falls and other cities will see reduced Via
service.
" In growing markets, we are adding
more frequencies to meet customer demand,"
said Laliberte.
" In addition, mandatory services in regions
where there are limited transportation
alternatives will remain.
" We are not eliminating rail service on
any routes where we operate today and we
are maintaining the flexibility to adjust
service levels in the future, as customer
needs evolve."
Via notes it has reduced it management
workforce by 15 per cent since 2009.
The Harper government's recent budget
reduced subsidies to the passenger rail service
by $ 6.5 million this year, $ 15.1 million
in 2013- 14 and $ 19.6 million in 2014- 15.
jenny. ford@ freepress. mb. ca
Cash scarce
for Manitoba
entrepreneurs
MARTIN
CASH
Via cuts 200 jobs
in wake of budget
38 lost in Winnipeg with potential for more damage
By Steve Lambert and Jenny Ford
Aveos Fleet Performance seeks
approval to be sliced up and sold
By Ross Marowits
BORIS MINKEVICH / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Marc Laliberte, president and chief executive officer of Via Rail Canada, announces job losses and service cuts Wednesday.
B_ 04_ Jun- 28- 12_ FP_ 01. indd B4 6/ 27/ 12 11: 35: 14 PM
;