Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - July 28, 2015, Winnipeg, Manitoba
C M Y K PAGE B1
IMRIS's loss is our loss / B4
CITY & BUSINESS
CITY EDITOR: SHANE MINKIN 204- 697- 7292 I CITY. DESK@ FREEPRESS. MB. CA I WINNIPEGFREEPRESS. COM
TUESDAY, JULY 28, 2015 B 1
T HE glass ceiling may
be cracking, but city
hall still has a few
benchmarks to pass
before it can argue it's completely
broken for women in
municipal politics.
A woman sits on Mayor Brian Bowman's
executive policy committee, a
woman sits as the speaker, and for
the first time since 1998, a quarter of
councillors are women.
Coun. Jenny Gerbasi is the longestserving
councillor at city hall, and
said things haven't improved much
since she was elected in 1998 as councillor
in Fort Rouge- East Fort Garry,
but she remains hopeful it will.
She recalls back in 1998 while in
line to enter the chamber on her day
of inauguration, a male city councillor
made a " significantly demeaning"
comment, which prompted her to
send a letter to the unnamed councillor
stating she expected to be treated
with the same respect as any of the
councillors would be treated.
" I haven't seen a lot of change; we
happen to have four women on council,
which is a positive change," she
said, acknowledging the new mayor
has brought a more positive attitude.
" As we know, for the last 10 years
there have been challenges in the
workplace, being disrespectful and
the bullying that has been tolerated."
Of the 59 candidates who ran in last
year's civic election, only nine were
women.
" When I was first elected, people
would say to me, ' Why do you want to
go to that place? It is a total Old Boys
club,' and I thought being a mother of
three, a nurse, I thought maybe I'll
bring a different type of person to
city council," Gerbasi said.
After extensive research, the
United Nations concluded 30 per cent
is the minimal percentage of women
required in government for women's
concerns to be met; a benchmark
Winnipeg has never been able to
meet.
There hasn't been enough significant
research at the municipal level
to conclude exactly why women
aren't choosing to run for municipal
politics, said Angelia Wagner, a
PhD candidate at the University of
Alberta, who has studied women in
municipal elections.
Wagner notes research has pointed
to men being more socialized to think
about a career in politics or are more
confident to run for office regardless
of their financial or personal situation.
" There are some differences in
terms of attitude," she said. " But we
really don't know enough about what
is holding them back."
The importance in bridging this
gap is one that shouldn't be ignored,
she said. For example, women have
different views and needs on important
areas dealt with at the municipal
level such as public transit or economic
development, she said.
" Women have a particular set of
needs and interests in a wide range of
policy areas, so we need to have that
perspective brought on to municipal
council," Wagner said.
Coun. Devi Sharma ( Old Kildonan)
is the first woman to be elected
Speaker at city hall. She says the obvious
goal is to completely break the
glass ceiling, but the right step forward
is having women in visible roles
such as Speaker.
Meanwhile, within Bowman's inner
circle, Coun. Janice Lukes sits as the
lone female member of his EPC and
is also chairwoman of infrastructure
and public works.
As a woman, she feels equally treated
at city hall, and argues she can
easily shut down anyone who tries to
use her being a woman to question
her ability.
" Being the chair of public works is
interesting, so I will say I have had
some encounters where I feel the, ' Oh
you're a woman, what do you know?'
" she said, laughing at the absurdity
of the idea.
It's an attitude she says she quickly
shuts down through her passion and
extensive knowledge on everything
within her complex file.
Rookie Coun. Cindy Gilroy ( Daniel
McIntyre) acknowledged that as a
mother of two children, in the midst
of separating from her husband, she
had to make sure she had a support
system in place before felt she could
commit to such a time- consuming
job.
" For me, it is the work balance that
is difficult; you have to be on call
with you family, and then you are on
call with the citizens, and I think it is
balancing those priorities that might
scare women away," Gilroy said.
kristin. annable@ freepress. mb. ca
I SPENT the weekend trying to contact
Rinelle Harper's family over
the phone.
No answer.
I was looking for them because of
some potentially
good news flowing
from Saturday's
column ( So chief,
where are you
now? , July 25)
about the Harper
family's desperate
search for summer
employment
in the aftermath
of losing their
home at Garden
Hill First Nation to a suspected arson
two weeks ago.
Parents Julie and Caesar Harper and
their two teenage daughters, Rinelle
and Rayne, also lost their on- reserve
summer jobs in the Island Lakes area.
That's left them unable to pay the rent
for their home in the city.
Suddenly, 16- year- old Rinelle and
her family face the prospect of having
nowhere to live.
Prior to Rinelle's grandmother Carol
Harper calling the Free Press for help,
no one - including David Harper, the
grand chief of the northern chiefs organization
- was reaching out to support
the girl who was paraded before
the public last year as the nationally
celebrated survivor of a brutal beating
and sexual assault.
As such, Rinelle became the voice of
more than 1,000 voiceless missing and
murdered aboriginal woman and girls,
and the uncounted other victims of
violence like them.
It was Monday, just after 11 a. m.
when I finally reached a family member,
but to do it I had to drive to the
grandmother's home in the city's West
End.
" Rinelle just got out of recovery,"
Carol Harper said at the front door.
Her granddaughter had undergone
day surgery to repair an injury that
still hadn't healed eight months after
the attack.
That's not all that hasn't healed, in
her grandmother's opinion.
" I'm starting to feel that something
is starting to come back to her," Carol
said. " But she doesn't want to say."
Carol meant memories of what
happened by the downtown banks
of Assiniboine River last November
that the media was told Rinelle didn't
remember at that time.
Her grandmother senses Rinelle is
remembering what happened now.
Or at least some of it.
That's Carol's intuition at work.
And, undoubtedly, her years of experience
as a crisis worker in Garden
Hill. Because Rinelle hasn't told her
anything.
" I always talk to her," Carol said.
"' Anytime you need to, you can talk to
your grandmother.'"
But Rinelle has said nothing to her.
Rinelle was offered counselling at her
high school, according to her mother,
although it's not clear to me whether
Rinelle accepted it, or opened up in
any way if she did.
Her father, Caesar Harper, told me
last week his daughter is unaffected
by what happened last year.
" She's still the same" he said when I
asked. " I think she never changed. Not
one little bit."
Her grandmother knows better than
to believe Rinelle has been unaffected
psychologically or emotionally.
" She hasn't dealt with anything, yet,"
Carol said. " Those flashbacks will
come, eventually."
That's my own sense of it, too.
It's highly unlikely Rinelle isn't
coping in some way inwardly, even if
outwardly she seems the same to her
dad.
Especially given the nature of an
assault that left her near death and
the resulting national spotlight that
followed.
That's the kind of public exposure
sexual assault victims rarely face.
Let alone a victim who is a minor.
A minor whose informed consent for
allowing herself to be so public with
her identity was questionable at the
time.
And still is.
But my main mission Monday was to
deliver news, not gather it.
Carol began by suggesting why I
might have trouble reaching her son
and daughter- in- law.
She said their cellphone and Internet
was cut off Monday and hydro and
water may follow.
" They have nothing."
The basic rent for next month is
$ 950.
Carol said they're paid up for this
month. It's August and maybe September,
they need help with.
Having heard that, it seemed like the
right time to tell Carol about the good
news that followed from Saturday's
column. One reader wants to start an
online crowd- sourcing campaign for
them to pay the rent. Someone else
has stepped up with potential term
positions for Julie, who's hoping to be
funded by her reserve to return to her
school course this fall. There may be
some work for Caesar, too. And there
was even this unexpected email that
arrived later Monday.
" Good day, Mr. Sinclair. I can give
Rinelle Harper summer employment,
too bad it is only for a month but
everything helps."
That offer came from. Don Courchene,
chief of staff for the Southern
Chiefs' Organization.
Which reminded me of David Harper
- who was asked by the family if
he could find a summer job for Rinelle
and didn't seem interested when we
spoke last week. He's the grand chief
of the northern chiefs.
So, you might be wondering, is the
offer from the southern chiefs a coincidence?
I think not.
But no matter.
If it is, no doubt it's a happy one for
Rinelle and family.
gordon. sinclair@ freepress. mb. ca
GORDON
SINCLAIR JR.
TREVOR HAGAN / THE CANADIAN PRESS FILES
Rinelle Harper made national headlines
after speaking out about her attack.
Delivering good news to a family in need
The Women's Democracy Project is a series of
news stories written in advance of the 100th anniversary
of Manitoba women's right to vote, which
occurred on Jan. 28, 1916. To commemorate this
important anniversary, the Winnipeg Free Press,
working with the Nellie McClung Foundation, is sponsoring
the Nellie Awards, given to women who have
worked tirelessly in the area of social justice, the arts
and promoting democracy. For more information or
to nominate, please go to wfp. to/ nellies.
WOMEN'S DEMOCRACY 100 th
A N N I V E R S A R Y
' Women have a particular set of needs
and interests in a wide range of policy areas,
so we need to have that perspective brought
on to municipal council'
- Angelia Wagner, a PhD candidate at the University of Alberta, who has
studied women in municipal elections
Looking for a breakthrough
It's no longer an Old Boys club, but glass ceiling remains at city hall
Kristin Annable
RUTH BONNEVILLE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Couns. Janice Lukes ( from left), Devi Sharma and Jenny Gerbasi, along with Cindy Gilroy, represent a quarter of Winnipeg's city council.
B_ 01_ Jul- 28- 15_ FP_ 01. indd B1 7/ 27/ 15 9: 36: 51 PM
;