Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - September 24, 2021, Winnipeg, Manitoba
C M Y K PAGE A1
SCU.MB.CA/SAVINGS
S TA R T I N G AT
1.05%*
INTEREST
ON SAVINGS
*Rate subject to change.
®
CELEBRATION
CONNECT WITH CANADA’S HIGHEST READERSHIP RATE WEATHER: PARTLY CLOUDY. HIGH 15— LOW 10
®
FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 24, 2021
FOUNDED IN 1872
THE Manitoba government
believes the economy can steadily
recover despite the defi cit surpass-
ing $2 billion, but the business com-
munity worries the bounce back
could still be derailed by the virus.
The provincial deficit topped $2
billion in the last fiscal year be-
cause of the massive cost of fight-
ing the COVID-19 pandemic and
the staggering loss in government
revenue.
On Thursday, the province re-
leased an audited final report for
the fiscal year that ended March
31, 2021. The public accounts
detail data from 140 government
entities, including Crown corpora-
tions such as Manitoba Liquor &
Lotteries and Manitoba Hydro.
The province took a big hit on
the revenue side, including the
loss of income tax from businesses
and the loss of gambling revenue
because casinos and VLT lounges
were closed for many months.
By far the biggest expense
was the ballooning cost of health
care. Hundreds of millions was
spent on pandemic aid programs,
such as wage subsidies for busi-
nesses and one-time $200 pay-
ments to every senior.
The Progressive Conservative
government said it expects the
deficit to shrink to $1.5 billion
this fiscal year as the economy
recovers.
Had the pandemic not occurred,
Manitoba would have had a
$357-million deficit.
“It really was a very challenging
year to predict,” Finance Minister
Scott Fielding said.
“You had to make a lot of policy
decisions on the fly, and that’s
what all governments did.”
Fielding said the government
is on track to balance its books
within eight years, unless there’s
a drastic wave of COVID-19 that
shuts down the economy again or
dries up U.S. demand for Mani-
toba goods.
Federal transfers are expected
to jump, partly due to a recent
child-care funding agreement
the province signed with Ottawa.
Based on various government,
bank and industry projections, the
Manitoba government projects
its real gross domestic product to
grow by 5.5 per cent in this fiscal
year, and 3.7 in 2022-23.
Pandemic costs
push deficit past
$2B; biz, labour
concerned
DYLAN ROBERTSON
EMOTION and anger over pandem-ic public health orders have hit new Manitoba Premier Kelvin
Goertzen right where he lives.
The longtime Progressive Conserva-
tive Steinbach MLA said Thursday in
some instances, the vitriol has erupted
in threats of violence against him and
his family.
“I won’t go into the details, and a lot
of them have been handled by law en-
forcement, and I appreciate that they
take those things seriously. But there’s
no doubt we’ve faced that and probably
elected officials across the country
have,” Goertzen said.
Some provincial government elected
officials and public health experts
have received threats following the
imposition of pandemic restrictions. In
July, Dr. Brent Roussin, the chief pro-
vincial public health officer, revealed
he and his family had been threatened
and that there had been “suspicious ac-
tivity” around his home that required
the involvement of law enforcement
officials.
Goertzen said he continues to sup-
port current public health orders,
including vaccine mandates and proof-
of-vaccination protocols, to help keep
COVID-19 in check, thereby ensuring
all Manitobans can get the health care
they need.
“I think what we’ve done now on
proof of vaccinations… is the right
thing for where we are right now,” he
said in his first extended interview
since becoming premier after Brian
Pallister stepped down last month.
“Do I like it? I don’t like it. Do I want
to see it persist for a long time? Of
course not. From my perspective, the
sooner we don’t need it, the better. But
I also know that as premier and as an
elected official, I have a responsibility
to do my best to make sure people can
get surgeries, and they can get medi-
cal treatment.”
Goertzen said he has endured many
awkward and angry conversations in
his home constituency as he tried to
make the government’s case for vac-
cine mandates and other restrictions
while trying not to harden the position
of constituents opposed to vaccina-
tions and pandemic public health
measures.
“(Steinbach) is a strong conservative
riding, and there are many who dis-
agree with our decisions. I’ve heard all
of those things, and I’ve heard them in
emotional ways,” he said. “We’ve lost
friends that we’ve had for a lifetime
and we may never get them back. So
that’s been really difficult.”
However, while he doesn’t want to
provoke the anti-vaccination/anti-
restriction crowd, Goertzen made it
clear the government has introduced
measures such as vaccine mandates
that infringe on the rights of unvacci-
nated Manitobans out of necessity, not
preference.
“Sometimes we’re just choosing
between bad options,” he said. “I think
that in the short term, the proof of
vaccination — while I don’t like it and
I don’t want it long term — is a bet-
ter place to be than having to cancel
15,000 surgeries.”
Goertzen’s clear support for vaccine
mandates and proof-of-vaccination
cards comes as the two candidates
vying to become the next leader of the
Progressive Conservatives and next
premier have raised questions about
what they would do to change public-
health orders.
One, former MP Shelly Glover, says
she opposes mandates but would be
willing to change her mind if she could
be convinced by public health offi-
cials. The other, MLA Heather Stefan-
son, has said she opposes “mandatory
vaccination” but supports “vaccine
mandates,” a semantic sleight of hand
that some political observers believe
was an attempt to curry the favour of
anti-vaccination party members.
Goertzen threatened over health orders
DAN LETT
JOHN WOODS / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS
Manitoba Premier Kelvin Goertzen says he’s tried to convince angry constituents that getting vaccinated and abiding by restrictions are necessary measures to fight the pandemic.
Interim premier stands by government actions as ‘right thing,’ reveals lifelong friendships in Steinbach jeopardized
● GOERTZEN, CONTINUED ON A2
MANITOBA Hydro has reported a
$20-million increase in net income
thanks mainly to export sales made
possible by the Keeyask northern dam
— an NDP project the Tory govern-
ment has railed against.
The increase is primarily from
higher out-of-province revenues and
firm export sales contracts made
possible by the 695-megawatt Keeyask
project under construction in north-
ern Manitoba and the 500-kilovolt
Manitoba-Minnesota transmission line
completed last year, says Manitoba
Hydro’s annual report, which was
released Thursday.
The provincially owned utility
reported a total consolidated net
income of $119 million for the fiscal
year ending March 31, 2021. Revenues
from out-of-province electricity sales
totalled $611 million — an increase of
$143 million from the previous year.
“We will build on our clean energy
advantage to help the province and the
country decarbonize,” president and
CEO Jay Grewal said in the report.
She noted that vehicle manufactur-
ers are moving away from combus-
tion engines toward electric vehicles,
and that Manitoba Hydro “is well-
positioned to play an important role in
shaping the changing energy land-
scape for the benefit of this province.”
That type of positive outlook and
analysis were nowhere to be found
in a report by former Saskatchewan
premier Brad Wall in February. The
former conservative leader slammed
the ex-NDP government and Manitoba
Hydro officials for overestimating the
potential for export sales needed to
justify building the Keeyask generat-
ing station and the Bipole III trans-
mission line that together ran $3.7
billion over budget.
Wall’s report, commissioned by then-
premier Brian Pallister, said the former
NDP government did little to prevent
costs from spiralling and was more fo-
cused on getting the projects completed.
Keeyask and Bipole III were built
over the last 15 years and Manitoba
Hydro’s debt has tripled in that time to
more than $23 billion.
On Thursday, when asked to
comment about Keeyask receiving
credit for Hydro’s increase in net
income, Crown Services Minister Jeff
Wharton thanked the construction
workers building the massive project
that started to come online this year.
“First, I want to be clear on a group
that has unfortunately been forgotten,
which are the fine folks contributing
to the construction of the Keeyask
Generating Station. They are doing a
tremendous job, under exceptional cir-
cumstances,” Wharton said in an email.
“Our issue lies with the NDP’s mis-
management of Manitoba Hydro. This
is why we remain committed to imple-
menting the Wall report recommenda-
tions, and strengthening our commit-
ment to better protect Manitobans
from the mistakes and decisions made
by the former government.”
Adrien Sala, the NDP critic for
Manitoba Hydro, said its annual
report shows the PC government has
misled Manitobans.
Keeyask dam increases Manitoba Hydro’s net income by $20M
CAROL SANDERS
● DEFICIT, CONTINUED ON A2
● KEEYASK, CONTINUED ON A2
BACK HOME
Jets open camp, captain cools hype train
C1
A_01_Sep-24-21_FP_01.indd A1 2021-09-23 11:02 PM
;