Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - January 8, 2025, Winnipeg, Manitoba
PRODUCED BY
JAN. 10-12
RBC Convention
Centre
WINNIPEGRENOVATIONSHOW.COM
SCAN QR CODE &
BUY TICKETS ONLINE
Promo Code:
FREEPRESS
2-FOR-1
*On Regular Adult Admission Only
COURTESY OF:
COURTESY OF:
SERVING MANITOBA SINCE 1872. FOREVER WITH YOUR SUPPORT.
WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 8, 2025
WEATHER
CLOUDY. HIGH -9 — LOW -10
ARTS
HOMEMADE SERIES A FEAST FOR LOCAL COOKS / C1
Man dies
in HSC ER
waiting room
eight hours
after arriving
CHRIS KITCHING
WINNIPEG’S Health Sciences Centre
has launched an investigation into the
Tuesday-morning death of a mid-
dle-aged man who spent eight hours
in the emergency department waiting
room after arriving by ambulance.
The man’s death immediately raised
comparisons to the tragic end of
double-amputee Brian Sinclair’s life in
2008 following more than 30 hours in
the same waiting room.
The ER was well over capacity and
staff were dealing with several high
acuity — seriously unwell — patients
and an internal bottleneck in moving
them when they noticed the man’s
condition had significantly worsened
in the waiting room, Dr. Shawn Young,
chief operating officer of the central
Winnipeg hospital, told reporters at a
Tuesday-afternoon news conference.
“We had a number of admitted pa-
tients in the (ER), and we were unable
to get them into beds and into the
facility because patients within HSC
that we need to get out, we’ve not been
able to successfully get them back out
to their communities or their residence
in a timely manner,” he said.
“The whole health system was
backed up that way.”
Young said a detailed and thorough
investigation of the man’s death and
all potentially contributing factors is
underway to determine if it will be
deemed a critical incident.
Young said the man, who arrived by
ambulance shortly after midnight, was
assessed, triaged and directed to the
waiting room with instructions to let
staff know if his condition changed or
worsened.
Officials did not say why he was
taken to the ER.
He was classified as a low-acuity pa-
tient, Young said, noting people in that
category can face waits of 10 hours or
more, while high-acuity patients are
seen first.
As many as 100 patients were in the
ER (in the waiting area or undergoing
treatment) at times in the 24 hours up
to Tuesday afternoon.
Of that number, about 50 were in the
waiting room when the man was there,
and all six resuscitation beds were full.
While the ER was over capacity, the
situation was “not completely abnor-
mal” because the department typically
has more than 70 or 80 patients, some-
times up to 100, Young said.
“When we see cold weather like this,
we do have a number of patients that
come in seeking shelter and safety as
well, and that was a factor in the wait-
ing room,” he said.
Young said he did not yet know how
many times the man was reassessed
by staff after being triaged, but
low-acuity patients are typically reas-
sessed every couple of hours, he said,
noting the frequency of reassessments
is affected when the ER has a high
number of patients.
Staff noticed the man’s condition had
deteriorated shortly before 8 a.m. It ap-
peared he had vital signs when he was
moved to a resuscitation room, where a
pulse could no longer be detected and
he was pronounced dead, Young said.
Auto insurance rates going up by 5.7%
T
HE Public Utilities Board has or-
dered a 5.7 per cent rate increase
for vehicle insurance — nearly
double the rate sought by Manitoba
Public Insurance — blaming the
Crown corporation for digging itself
into a deep financial hole.
Beginning April 1, rates will
increase $50.84 per year ($4.24 per
month) for the average passenger ve-
hicle. Exact increases will vary from
driver to driver depending on factors
including driving record, claims histo-
ry and place of residence.
In the order, dated Tuesday, the
PUB took MPI to task for its failure
to consult actuary forecasting in its
application.
MPI requested a three per cent
increase to driver insurance in its 2025
rate application — well below its actu-
ary’s recommendation that exceeded
six per cent.
The PUB found no evidence the
three per cent increase would help
MPI dig itself out of the $130-million
hole it posted in the 2023-24 fiscal
year.
“While MPI put forward the pro-
posal that it could return to financial
stability within five years, the board
is not confident of that based on the
evidence adduced at this hearing,” the
PUB board wrote in its decision.
During the three-week public hear-
ing in October and November 2024,
MPI president and chief executive
officer Satvir Jatana said the Crown
corporation settled on a three per cent
ask based on various circumstanc-
es, including maintaining ratepayer
affordability.
In its annual report, MPI said its
massive deficit was due to a historic
hailstorm and 10-week strike in 2023,
along with major cost overruns on its
IT overhaul, Project Nova.
Katrine Dilay, a lawyer for the Pub-
lic Interest Law Centre who represent-
ed the Manitoba branch of the Consum-
ers’ Association of Canada during the
hearings, said the request was made
based on a feeling, not rooted in fact.
NICOLE BUFFIE
Canadian leaders slam Trump’s 51st state claims
WASHINGTON — Prime Minister
Justin Trudeau clapped back Tuesday
at Donald Trump’s escalating claims
that Canada would be better off if it
became the 51st state, and has called
for an in-person meeting with pre-
miers in Ottawa next week to address
this country’s relationship with the
United States.
Trudeau and the premiers have met
virtually twice since November to
negotiate a response to Trump’s threat
to slap Canada and Mexico with 25 per
cent import tariffs the day he takes of-
fice. That threat is now imminent, with
inauguration day less than two weeks
away and Trump insisting Tuesday in
a news conference that he will follow
through with the tariffs.
The Prime Minister’s Office said late
Tuesday Trudeau and premiers will
meet in person today in Ottawa, days
before that would happen.
Trump on Tuesday also repeated
his insistence that Canada should join
the U.S. While he suggested he would
not rule out the use of military force
to seize control of the Panama Canal
and Greenland, saying they were vital
to American security, he did not go
that far with Canada. Instead he said
he would rely on “economic force” to
merge the two countries.
“You get rid of that artificially
drawn line and you take a look at what
that looks like, and it would also be
much better for national security,”
Trump said, referring to the border
between Canada and the U.S.
“And don’t forget, we basically pro-
tect Canada.”
Trudeau, who has until now not
directly commented on Trump’s re-
peated and escalating comments about
annexing Canada, appeared to have
had enough.
“There isn’t a snowball’s chance in
hell that Canada would become part of
the United States,” Trudeau said in a
statement posted to social media.
“Workers and communities in both
our countries benefit from being each
other’s biggest trading and security
partners.”
Trump first quipped about Canada
becoming the 51st state in November,
when the prime minister and Finance
Minister Dominic LeBlanc dined with
the president-elect at Mar-a-Lago in
Florida to discuss his tariff threats.
LeBlanc has repeatedly dismissed
the idea as “a joke” but the government
is not laughing now.
Foreign Affairs Minister Mélanie
Joly posted on X that his comments
“show a complete lack of understand-
ing of what makes Canada a strong
country.”
The Liberal party posted a map
of North America on X labelling the
United States and Canada as “Not the
United States,” with the caption: “For
anyone who may be confused.”
In an apparent response, Trump
posted two maps on Truth Social: one
labelling both countries together as
“United States,” and the other with
the two countries covered in stars and
stripes.
KELLY GERALDINE MALONE
MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS
BURNING CRISIS
A person walks by the charred remains of the vacant Holy Ascension Greek Orthodox Church in Point Douglas Tuesday, which was destroyed
by fire Monday night. The crisis of repeated fires in vacant properties reached record levels last year and shows no signs of slowing / B1
● STATE, CONTINUED ON A3 ● HSC, CONTINUED ON A2
● RATES, CONTINUED ON A2
PUB rejects MPI’s 3% hike request, ‘not confident’ amount would be enough
;