Winnipeg Free Press

Winnipeg Free Press (Newspaper) - October 29, 2025, Winnipeg, Manitoba (204) 237-4295 (HAWK) www.hawktrucks.com 415 Dawson Road North • Wpg, MB Hawk Auto & Truck Accessories TRUCK • VAN • CAR • SUV • ACCESSORIES Your Car & Truck Accessory Headquarters! SHOP LOCAL! Support Your Local Merchants, Call Shelley Promotions at 204-233-1159 or ShelleyOstrove@gmail.com to book your Nov. 27th, 2025 ad. C O L D B O O S T C o l d W e a t h e r ’ s C o m i n g . A r e Y o u R e a d y t o B ? $19.50 Our South Location 452 Dovercourt dr, winnipeg, MB R3Y 1G4 204-488-0500 www.manitobabattery.com Our South Location 1026 Logan Ave, Winnipeg, MB R3E 1P4 204-783-8787 T H E o o s t 859 Westminster 204-783-5097 The Forks Market 204-957-5097 and now Tall Grass sur la Seine 204-942-5097 N-390 Provencher Blvd. St Boniface Free parking! tallgrassbakery.ca holiday treats ORDER AHEAD for your favourite treats to enjoy over the weeks to come Sweet • Vínarterta • Tall Grass fruit cake • Tall Grass fruit bread • Assorted pies • Seasonal cookies MANITOBA’S NUMBER ONE RATED DUCT CLEANING COMPANY Top Choice Award winner for Best Duct Cleaning in Winnipeg for the past three years UNLIMITED VENT & DUCT CLEANING FOR $ 199 95 (431) 688-5872 info@ultravac.net / www.ultravac.net Expiry Date: November 30, 2025 perogyplanet.com 1411 Main St. 4-2001 Portage Ave. 36-1128 Henderson Hwy 805-1615 Regent Ave 11-845 Dakota St. One Per Person. One-time Use. Expires November 30, 2025 One package of each: • Any flavour perogies • Any flavour cabbage rolls • any flavor meatballs $ 24.25 1669 Main St. (at Jefferson) 204.772.6678 See store for details 24” Snowblower STORM 2435 Electric hand warmers, electric start, power steer, headlight $ 1,000 BRAND NEW Beat the Snow Sale! www.washmethod.com Wash Method Car Wash & Detail Centre 690 St. Anne’s Rd Buy 1 Get 1 at HALF PRICE Any Exterior Wash or VIP inside out wash. OFFER ENDS NOV. 23, 2025 No coupon necessary. Valid anytime. Not valid for subscriptions, or full detailing services. 219 St. Mary’s Rd. Ph# 204-233-7943 Hours: Mon - Sat 8 am - 9 pm / Sun 9 am - 9 pm BREAKFAST SPECIAL 2 eggs, hashbrowns, toast with a choice of ham, bacon, or sausage. $ 8.95 Available 8-10am 7 days/wk BREAKFAST COMBO 2 eggs, 1 slice of ham, 2 strips of bacon, 1 sausage. $ 11.95 Available 8-10am 7 days/wk Hot November Weekly Specials Monday - 2 pc Chicken Combo Tuesday - Lot-O Burger Combo Wednesday - Beef or Chicken Gyro Combo Thursday - Poor Boy 12’ sub Combo Friday - Chicken Club House Combo Saturday - Chicken Finger Combo Sunday - Hot Beef or Turkey Combo $ 1 5 . 6 5 All combos come with fries, coleslaw and a drink A’l Epi De ble-French Bakery Valid with coupon only. Expiry date: November 30, 2025 1757 Main Street Ph: 204-334-2526 online order at frenchbakery.online BUY ONE BREAD AND GET THE 2ND ONE AT HALF PRICE. ! ! WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 29, 2025WINNIPEGFREEPRESS.COM ● A5 NEWS I TOP NEWS Stefanson’s legacy tarnished in absence of apology O NE of the most troubling as- pects about former Premier Heather Stefanson’s 2023 ethics breach isn’t just what she did — it’s that she still doesn’t think she did anything wrong. Stefanson was fined $18,000 for try- ing to push through a licence for a Sio Silica sand mine project after losing the Oct. 3, 2023, provincial election. She paid the fine last week, according to House Speaker Tom Lindsey. But she remains defiant. Ethics Commissioner Jeffrey Schnoor’s report on the breach, re- leased in May, was damning. It found that Stefanson, then-deputy premier Cliff Cullen and then-economic devel- opment minister Jeff Wharton violated the province’s Conflict of Interest Act by trying to approve a licence for the proposed mining project after the Progressive Conservative government was defeated. All three ministers pushed to have a Class 2 licence under the Environ- ment Act approved for Sio Silica, days before the new NDP government was sworn into office. That violated the “caretaker con- vention,” a constitutional principle in Canada that prohibits governments from making major policy decisions once a general election is called, unless it relates to an urgent matter of public importance, like a natural disaster. What made this scandal even more severe is Stefanson attempted to get the licence approved not just after the election was called, but after her gov- ernment was defeated at the polls. “The efforts to have the project licence approved by Ms. Stefanson, Mr. Cullen and Mr. Wharton were taken despite their knowledge that voters had rejected the former government and had placed their trust in a new government,” Schnoor wrote in his report. “All three knew the require- ments of the caretaker convention and both Mr. Cullen and Mr. Wharton had been given specific warnings that approving the project licence during the transition period would breach the convention.” The facts of the case are straight- forward. The Sio Silica proposal was undergoing a detailed environmental assessment by provincial regulators. There were serious concerns raised by environmental officials and others about potential groundwater contam- ination and the project’s long-term safety. Instead of letting that process run its course, Stefanson decided to intervene. Worse, she did so after her government lost the election. She pressed officials to expedite a decision. That is textbook political interfer- ence. The licence was ultimately not approved, but the fact that the person holding the province’s highest office couldn’t see that she was breaking the law — or worse, didn’t care — is what makes this so egregious. It was an attack on democracy. “The caretaker convention stands at the very core of our democracy,” wrote Schnoor. “The legitimacy of a govern- ment depends on the support of the electorate, expressed in elections. A government that loses an election has lost the confidence of the people and has lost the legitimacy to do anything beyond maintaining the status quo until the new government can take office.” For a former premier to reject those findings — or at least show indiffer- ence to them — from an independent officer of the legislative assembly is nothing short of stunning. After Schnoor’s report was released, Stefanson released a statement saying she spoke to the NDP about the project. “I had no obligation to do so but reached out to the incoming govern- ment and fully considered their views before deciding on what to do,” Ste- fanson said in a statement earlier this year, noting a licence was never issued to Sio Silica. The fact the former premier still re- fuses to acknowledge the ethical impli- cations of her actions speaks volumes about her integrity. She’s treating the commissioner’s findings like a political disagreement rather than a legal deter- mination by an independent officer of the legislature. That’s the truly galling part. This isn’t a partisan witch hunt. It’s an official finding under Manitoba’s own laws. The ethics commissioner is an impartial watchdog, tasked with upholding the integrity of public office. When that office determines the pre- mier broke the law, you’d expect some humility — maybe even an apology. Instead, Stefanson is showing defiance. The former premier argues she didn’t stand to gain financially from the proposed mining project. That’s not the point. The point is she attempted to make a major policy decision when she no longer had the moral authority to do so. Manitoba voters rejected her govern- ment and she was no longer in a posi- tion to make decisions on their behalf. The $18,000 fine — though unprece- dented in Manitoba — is a slap on the wrist compared to the damage done to public trust. What really matters now is whether political leaders, from all parties, learn from this. Stefanson clearly hasn’t learned that lesson. In her mind, she’s the victim of over- zealous oversight — a premier pun- ished for trying to grow the economy. That’s what makes this entire epi- sode so troubling. It’s not just that she broke the law, it’s that even after being caught, she still believes she’s above it. If Stefanson wants to salvage what’s left of her tattered political legacy, she should do the right thing and acknowl- edge wrongdoing. She should issue an unqualified public apology. Anything less would leave an endur- ing black mark on her time in politics. tom.brodbeck@freepress.mb.ca TOM BRODBECK OPINION MIKE DEAL / FREE PRESS FILES For former Premier Heather Stefanson to reject findings from an independent officer of the legislative assembly is nothing short of stunning. ;